Do Events Inside Black Holes Happen?

Channel:PBS Space Time · Length:14:24 · Published:2015-08-19 · Views:3171893

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A PBS Space Time episode asking what black holes really are and whether events can happen inside them. It covers event horizons, time dilation and common misconceptions about black holes.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters recommend it as an accessible but deep explanation of black holes that corrects popular misconceptions.

This is mind blowing...shatters my misconception of blackholes — HN, 2018

Cosmology & astrophysics

Subtitles (excerpt)

[MUSIC PLAYING] I'm sure you've read, seen, and heard a lot about black holes. Well, today, I'm going to try to make you rethink all of it, down to what the term "black hole" even means. [THEME MUSIC] Today's episode, we'll only talk about black holes from the perspective of classical general relativity. That means no Hawking radiation, no string theory, and no quantum anything-- baby steps. Trust me, if I do this right, it'll be mind blowing enough. Now, it's a lot harder to say what I want to say about black holes if I make this video self-contained. To treat gravity Einsteinially rather than Newtonianially from the outset, it will help a lot if I can rely on technical terms like "geodesic" or "flat spacetime" and if I can draw a spacetime diagram or two. We all need to be on the same page with this vocabulary. So if you need a refresher, go watch our relativity playlist. And finally, to minimize miscommunication, I need a favor from you. I need you to put your preconceptions about black holes aside and for the next few minutes, become "tabula rasa" and let me tell you a story about me, a pony, and a very acrobatic monkey. Suppose that I'm very far from a black hole and there's a pony orbiting the black hole.

On Hacker News

> [VIDEO] This is mind blowing...shatters my misconception of blackholes....is there any more books on this? — pwaai, 2018-02
PBS Spacetime is a great series, and delves deep enough for interested layman as well as practitioners to be interested. I find the videos really good. Here is a link to one of many on black holes. [VIDEO] — czbond, 2019-01
The youtube channel PBS Spacetime has some really great videos about how black holes work, I would start with this one: [VIDEO] — drewrv, 2018-10
There is a fascinating PBS Space Time video[1] about black holes that questions the very existence of whatever is "inside" a black hole. They point out that as you approach a black hole, your proper time is advancing slower and slower when compared to an observer located far away from the black hole (like us, on Earth). That means that from the point of view of this far observer, nothing happens … — grondilu, 2018-02
A better way of thinking about the event horizon is that it is the boundary beyond which events happening cannot be assigned a 'when' in our universe - i.e. the object falling 'in' to the black hole is never seen to pass this horizon, but to the object it seems that they do, however those events happen to it after an infinite time in our universe, i.e. never, due to time dilation. The contents of… — grkvlt, 2018-02

Related videos