The Most Common Cognitive Bias

Channel:Veritasium · Length:4:44 · Published:2014-02-24 · Views:17429257

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A Veritasium video that runs the 2-4-8 rule-guessing puzzle on people to show how they test only examples that confirm their hypothesis. It uses this to illustrate confirmation bias and falsification.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as a clear demonstration of confirmation bias and the value of trying to break your own hypothesis.

I would suggest this video by Veritasium, which also touches on this, at a very fundamental level — HN, 2021

Psychology & human behavior · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

I'm gonna give you guys three numbers. A three number sequence and I have a rule in mind that these three numbers obey and I want you to try to figure out what that rule is. But the way you can get information is by proposing your own set of three numbers, to which I will say yes that follows my rule or no it doesn't follow my rule. And then you can propose what you think the rule is. Is that fair? Okay, so here are the three numbers: 2, 4, 8. 2, 4, 8. You don't need to continue the sequence, you can propose a totally different sequence, whatever you want to propose and I will simply say yes or no 2, 4, 8? 16, 32 16 32 and 64? Those also follow my rule. ok What's the rule you think? Multiply by 2? That is... not my rule. What? That's not my rule. But you're allowed, if you want, propose 3 other numbers. 3, 6, 12. 3, 6, 12? Follows my rule. 10, 20, 40. That follows the rule. I'm still multiplying by two I know [Laughter] I know what you're doing. and yes it follows my rule but no it's not my rule. 5, 10 and 20? Follows my rule 100, 200, 400? Follows my rule 500, 1000, 2000 Follows my rule. You want me to keep going? But do I just keep going? You going to tell me or what? [Laughter] Am I doing it the wrong way? Am I approaching this the wrong way?

On Hacker News

Veritasium has a great video[1] about people’s cognitive bias towards using examples that prove their mental model, rather than using examples that disprove their mental model. But if you want to actually confirm you have accurate understanding of something, testing examples that don't fit your metal model is the workable methodology (i.e. use a null hypothesis). Testing examples that do match yo… — avianlyric, 2023-12
Experimental science is all based around ruling out the null hypothesis. For that it needs to be falsifiable . The hypothesis 'the dog can differentiate between A and B' is very hard to falsify. Because the dog could differentiate, but choose to not act. You would need a fairly complete understanding of the dogs mental workings, and scanners to study them. On the other hand, 'the dog can't differ… — nightcracker, 2021-09
Veritasium, a pretty interesting youtube channel, posted a video on this experiment a while back. I found the discussion afterwards to be more thought-provoking than this article. [VIDEO] — drhdylan88, 2015-07
Related: [VIDEO] TL;DW: I have a rule and you need to figure it out. The rule relates to a sequence of three numbers. You can propose a sequence and I’ll tell you yes/no if it meets the rule. I’ll give you the first sequence to get you started: sequence: 2,4,8 passes: Yes — adverbly, 2023-06
Very interesting! This reminds me of a Veritasium video I watched years ago, called “The most common cognitive bias” [1]. People don’t explore solution spaces as effectively as they think they do. [1] [VIDEO] — oneofthefirst, 2021-11

Related videos