Keynote: The Last Hope for Scala's Infinity War - John A. De Goes

Channel:Scalapeño · Length:45:03 · Published:2018-07-10 · Views:36407

Watch on YouTube

Summary

John A. De Goes's Scalapeno keynote argues that Scala's popularity is declining because of compile times, complexity and compatibility problems. He proposes a path for Scala to survive, including a simplified functional subset.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in Scala and language-marketing discussions for its accurate account of Scala's pain points and its argument that a language's pitch must address a real developer pain.

John De Goes describes pain points quite accurately in Scalapeno keynote — HN, 2018

Programming language design · Functional programming · Software practice, open source & careers

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] thank you for inviting me to this wonderful conference this is the first time I have been to Israel and it's a beautiful country and everyone I've met has just shown me nothing but kindness and hospitality so it's a pleasure for me to be here and for me to speak with you all on a topic that's very near and dear to my heart so I'm gonna give you a bit of a warning I've some stuff to say today and and you may not like it in fact probably at some point during this presentation you're gonna be like John's a hater John hates Scala and at that point part of your brain is gonna switch off and you're gonna be like ignoring everything that I have to say after the fact so I want to prevent that from happening and assure you that I'm actually not a Scala hater you haven't seen my talks on Haskell and another programming languages it's the languages I love the most that I actually spend the most time critiquing and I think that in the case of Scala there are some problems and I think that one of the things that we can do if we really love the Scala programming language and we want it to be as successful as possible I don't mean successful in a niche way I mean as successful as we all know and believe

On Hacker News

There are certainly folks that argue the language it too big. Here's a great talk arguing that a lot of language features should be eliminated and Scala should be made a functional programming language: [VIDEO] I'm personally in the camp of "keep Scala huge and weird and multi-paradigm, but just make less breaking changes and focus all efforts on making the ecosystem more stable". — MrPowers, 2021-03
Scala is interesting language, but I wish it had tighter focus. John De Goes describes pain points quite accurately in Scalapeno keynote: [VIDEO] — metalrain, 2018-07
Yep, there is even a talk on the Scala Infinity War which argues for one subset version of Scala that it needs in order to survive: [VIDEO] For me, Scala is a multi-paradigm language with tons of features. The community just needs different types of style guides for different apps. vars are horrifying for the functional crowd, but cool with me for example. — MrPowers, 2021-02
Weird nitpick, but "No Makefiles required" is an odd selling point to me. I haven't seen or used a Makefile in eons, and I would wager a decent chunk of programmers never needed to. I'm not sure how to describe the feeling this creates. Like...I can feel the authors other experiences shine through or something to that effect. There was a talk awhile ago by John A. De Goes where he asserted roughl… — emccue, 2020-08
> Egison is a programming language that realizes non-linear pattern-matching against non-free data types. It's a what? Can someone ELI5 this for a lowly Python and JS dev - why would I want this? ---- I watched a talk about Scala's future [0] recently, in which the presenter compared the taglines of a few different languages (Go, Rust, Erlang, Scala), and how they relate to business pains or non-… — vosper, 2018-07

Related videos