China’s Vanishing Muslims: Undercover In The Most Dystopian Place In The World

Channel:VICE News · Length:31:47 · Published:2019-06-29 · Views:11565739

Watch on YouTube

Summary

VICE News reporter Isobel Yeung goes undercover as a tourist in Xinjiang, documenting heavy surveillance, policing and internment of Uighurs. It also covers children taken into state-run institutions.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it as first-hand, independent reporting on Xinjiang that does not rely on state-sanctioned access.

here's a very thorough look from an established news source — HN, 2020

Privacy, surveillance & cybercrime · Geopolitics & foreign policy · Media, journalism & propaganda

Subtitles (excerpt)

[Music] [Applause] will hide each other a special 2004 spirit pass on security [Music] [Music] and I think my illness limits of me tomorrow ladies and gentlemen and all our frequent flyers [Music] so no jungle default Devon feel I can be under sidewalk you should we love make sure she'll do a neo we talk later we're in Xinjiang a place unlike anywhere on earth it's home to the Wiegand mostly Muslim minority who've lived here for centuries shinjang has long been a pressure point where China's ethnic tensions have played out but in the last decade handful of violent incidents have disturbed the region it's been three days since bloody riots broke out pitting ethnic we're Muslims against the dominant Han Chinese China blames this unrest on Islamic extremism and ethnic separatism their response to detain over 1 million people in massive new facilities where they're taken for so-called re-education the government has presented these as joyful training schools where they're correcting extremist behavior for the US Defense Department has called them concentration camps in an effort to clamp down on information leaking out of the region journalists have been prevented from reporting freely here

On Hacker News

Most people would be unequivocally against slave concentration camps. Do not confuse lack of action with lack of caring. Effective action may require collective action. But individually, most people care. Yet, collectively, they cannot seem to do anything meaningful. You are making a statement that is the definition of an ecological fallacy [0] The article you pointed out is hardly balanced. The … — network2592, 2022-01
> Almost everything ughyur and xinjiang related has pretty much been shown to be propaganda and from highly questionable sources Do you have any evidence for that whatsoever? In contrast, here's a very thorough look from an established news source: [VIDEO] — _bxg1, 2020-03
Yes, totalitarian dictatorships are a literal alternative to Democracy, though I feel we're nitpicking on the semantics of my words here. When I say I don't see Totalitarian Dictatorships as an alternative, I don't mean in the literal sense, I mean in the viable sense. In the literal sense, yes, it's an alternative to Democracy. As is building a house on sand is a literal but not viable alternati… — LilBytes, 2019-08
I'm personally opposed to the idea of visiting certain countries, such as China and North Korea, to 'see for yourself', especially when you don't know the language, when you're not willing to risk your life to understand and uncover the parts the government doesn't want you to see, like VICE did in Xinjiang: [VIDEO] That being said, if you go then please try to walk into a random hotel/apartment … — legofr, 2021-12
> Youtube videos from randos aren't very good sources Sure But a rado guy who have not even had the first-hand information, would be an even worse source. That's always been my #1 rule of assessing the reliability of any news reporting. My point still stands, the mainstream media's report on Xinjiang is lazy, they have no first-hand deep reporting. Note that the early reporting by Vice is the rig… — justicezyx, 2021-06

Related videos