Watching This Video Disqualifies You From Jury Duty for Life

Channel:CGP Grey · Length:4:30 · Published:2014-02-12 · Views:22425483

Watch on YouTube

Summary

CGP Grey explains jury nullification, a juror's power to acquit despite the law, and why mentioning it can get you struck from jury selection.

Why HN recommends it

HN links it as the clearest short explainer of jury nullification and how the jury system works, often in threads on prosecutors and trials.

Great video that explains this — HN, 2015

Law, policing & justice · Documentaries & storytelling

Subtitles (excerpt)

On a Jury you know your options: guilty, or not. But there's another choice that neither the judge nor the lawyers will tell you -- often because they're not allowed to and also it might better if you don't know. This video will tell you that third choice, but be warned: simply watching may prevent you from ever serving on a jury -- so this is your last chance to hit the pause button before you learn about... Jury nullification: when the defendant is 100% beyond-a-reasonable-doubt guilty but the jurors also think he shouldn't be punished. The jury can nullify the law and let him go free. But before your on your next jury and yell 'Null! Booya!' at the judge you should know that just talking about jury nullification in the wrong circumstances can get you arrested. Though a video such as this one, simply acknowledging the existence of jury nullification and in no way advocating it is totally OK. And, while we're at it: (CGP Grey is not a lawyer, this is not legal advice, it is meant for entertainment purposes only. Seriously, guy, don't do anything in a court of law based on what an Internet Video told you. No joke.) So why can't you do this? It's because nullification isn't in the law , but exists as a logical consequence of two other laws:

On Hacker News

I'm sorry, but that's a rather inaccurate view as to the justification for jury nullification. It is not a thing that's directly provided for in the law, it's a confluence of two legal principles: juries can't be held liable for their decisions, and the prohibition against double jeopardy. There's also the problem that that when people are told about nullification, they consider evidence less tha… — Karunamon, 2015-04
CGP Grey has a video discussing jury nullification, for those interested in a further explanation of the subject: [VIDEO] — cornstalks, 2022-08
Feels like a pretty unethical article on an 'ethical' website. They clearly have a bias on the issues of the cases which they didn't even need to mention. CGP Grey did a interesting video on this [VIDEO] CGP Grey claim now you know the idea you might not be able to use it. There have been a few arrests of different people advocating for jury nullification (Which I think only applies if you talk t… — aaron695, 2021-06
I'm aware of jury nullification (thank you cgp gray [1]) but afaik I don't think jury nullification can be equated to "doing nothing rather than doing the insane". Jury nullification have a lot of uncomfortable implications to the legal system and that's one of the reasons it's not shared to potential juries, but implicit asked. The systematic implication can be pararelled to politician's in the … — NalNezumi, 2024-07
A similar one that is also rarely attempted AFAIK is Jury Nullification [1] I've heard it suggested to be used to be disqualified for jury selection but have no idea how many people have actually tried to use it. i.e. that ones states to the lawyers during jury selection that they believe in the use of invoking it Here's [2] a video about it. [1] - [LINK] [2] - [VIDEO] — LinuxBender, 2023-03

Related videos