How Physicists Created a Holographic Wormhole in a Quantum Computer
Channel:Quanta Magazine · Length:17:04 · Published:2022-11-30 · Views:2387002
Summary
Quanta Magazine explains the 2022 experiment that claimed to create a holographic wormhole on Google's quantum computer. The description now notes that a later independent analysis questioned whether any wormhole was created.
Why HN recommends it
Initially praised as a nicely done explainer, it is now more often cited as an example of overhyped quantum coverage.
Quantum computing · Quantum physics
Subtitles (excerpt)
Nobody has seen a wormhole. Nobody has produced one. Nobody knows if it is just beautiful math, but without a physical reality. Well, we'll take the world's best quantum computer and see if we can map that into building a wormhole. And then it became just at the edge of what's possible. I think the discovery of the Higgs, which came about 10 years ago, was up to that point the most exciting point of my entire career. This, to me, is equally exciting. It can begin to explore quantum states that are very hard to realize in nature directly. Now, the wormhole becomes traversable. It opens. You really can go through. So, the story begins in 1935 when Einstein wrote a paper with Rosen, where the first time Einstein-Rosen bridges appear. And these are bridges that connect two seemingly unconnectable pieces of space-time. ER–Einstein and Rosen–they pointed out that solutions to general relativity allowed for two black holes, which are connected, but with a kind of bridge–what we call a wormhole. But that wormhole has the property of being non-traversable. Wormhole is a very unstable passage. It opens and it closes and it gets chaotic and it gets destroyed very fast. So Einstein, when he proposed the wormhole, he was very frustrated,
On Hacker News
The accompanying video was quite nicely done: [VIDEO] I have to say that I have a general suspicion of quantum computing research as it seems that the scientists could be making up success criteria as they go along and we'd have zero idea either way. That said, I respect these institutions enough to accept that people much more brilliant than myself are solving problems I can't begin to understan… — russellbeattie, 2022-11
Unfortunately I have not found this to be true (though it is in this case). There are quite a number of articles that are misleading or flat out false. The best example is the quantum wormhole article and video[0,1], because it is egregious and doesn't take much nuance or expertise see the issues. I'm glad they made a note and wrote a follow-up[2], but all this illustrates what is wrong with the … — godelski, 2024-11
I think it matters who we want to write papers to. Right now we write papers and abstracts to reviewers. That's because that's how we're measured and that's where we compete. But I'd say that we generally believe that papers are written to other researchers, which I agree that that should be the goal. But as this competition is increasing we're starting to write more to media as this can usually … — godelski, 2023-11
> For me the worst part of the video was at 11:53, where they showed a graph with a bright point labelled “negative energy peak” on it. The problem is that this is not a plot of data, it’s just a drawing, with no connection to the experiment. Lay people will think they are seeing actual data, so this is straightforward disinformation. This is exactly how I interpreted that part of the video [1], … — pera, 2022-12
Related videos
- Pitfall Classic Postmortem With David Crane Panel at GDC 2011 (Atari 2600) · GameSpot · 1:00:12
- The Virtual Production of The Mandalorian Season One · Industrial Light & Magic · 4:42
- The Quantum Conspiracy: What Popularizers of QM Don't Want You to Know · Google TechTalks · 1:03:43
- Quantum Computing for Computer Scientists · Microsoft Research · 1:28:22
- Quantum Entanglement & Spooky Action at a Distance · Veritasium · 9:15
- Quantum Fields: The Real Building Blocks of the Universe - with David Tong · The Royal Institution · 1:00:17
- The Physics and Philosophy of Time - with Carlo Rovelli · The Royal Institution · 54:54
- The Biggest Ideas in the Universe: Introduction · Sean Carroll · 6:33
- Demystifying the Higgs Boson with Leonard Susskind · Stanford · 1:15:08
- The more general uncertainty principle, regarding Fourier transforms · 3Blue1Brown · 18:06
- Visualization of Quantum Physics (Quantum Mechanics) · udiprod · 14:33
- Particles, Fields and The Future of Physics - A Lecture by Sean Carroll · Fermilab · 1:37:55
- Noether's Theorem and The Symmetries of Reality · PBS Space Time · 13:01
- A Brief History of Quantum Mechanics - with Sean Carroll · The Royal Institution · 56:11
- Bell's Theorem: The Quantum Venn Diagram Paradox · minutephysics · 17:34
- The Mathematics of Quantum Computers | Infinite Series · PBS Infinite Series · 12:35