“What is Success?” by Evan Czaplicki

Channel:Elm Europe · Length:47:52 · Published:2018-07-18 · Views:30645

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Elm creator Evan Czaplicki's 2018 Elm Europe talk on how to define success for an open source project and language community. It argues against judging projects by GitHub activity and touches on community expectations.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in debates over Elm's direction and open source health, with some praising its points about metrics and others finding its tone toward unhappy users hard to watch.

he raises some interesting points about how measuring projects by Github activity is strongly biased — HN, 2018

Programming language design · Functional programming · Software practice, open source & careers

Subtitles (excerpt)

right welcome everyone it's very exciting to be it the second film Europe I warn you I'm quite jet-lagged so I'm gonna do my best to be energetic but it's struggle okay so I've been working on an album for about six or seven years now and one of the thing that you sort of get used to over time or it's just part of the job is people on the internet telling you things so I collected some that I remembered some is wrong is Evan killing Elms momentum and when I first read I was like but I made it like this person nearly had a heart attack so a lot of people feel very mm strongly aggressively I'm not sure exactly how to say this but it's it's often hard to deal with these sorts of interactions so on some level it's kind of funny right like Elm is wrong the the post is kind of like a carrot like a self-parody but it's not like it's so over-the-top angry that you're like is this a joke about how angry people can be but anyway what ends up happening with these posts is like as time has gone on I kind of been used to it but a lot of people in the community end up engaging with these things so like with this one between hacker news our programming in our Elm more than 300 comments and so if these are taking 5 minutes 10 minutes like this is a

On Hacker News

Agreed; I think it's important to realize that a naive bias for action/productivity is not always the best thing. It's imperative to cultivate a good sense of what is worth doing, otherwise one will just produce a lot that will be irrelevant at best or garbage at worst. There are many "productive" people, but a question worth asking is how many of those actions result in lasting value, however yo… — ssivark, 2019-02
Interesting observation by Aaron Swartz. That could happen because the barrier to entry for adding to a text blurb is much lower than that for contributing to a code base — maybe because we practice the former for a decade in school. For code, ease of access (edit ability) is non-obvious and therefore, an important axis along which to evaluate open source projects. So, funnily enough, I agree wit… — ssivark, 2018-08
Why is the pace of releases an important metric for using a programming language? Focus on code quality, and maintenance simplicity. If anything, being able to use the same version for x years and having it be consistently better than any JS library/framework I used, means that the work done is of high quality. Maybe you should watch Evan's talks from various Elm conferences ( search on youtube, … — antouank, 2018-07
Language, its community and development model is a reflection of its creator and his philosophy. So Without meeting the creator Guido, through language and its community I can see is very humble and care about things besides solving computer science problems. May be this is one of the reasons of success of Python and its community which is open, humble, friendly and inclusive. In my startup we ha… — dragonsh, 2019-10
> You're saying a codebase of 5% JavaScript demands more JavaScript experience than a codebase of 100% JavaScript. A codebase of 100% Javascript does not usually mean 100% written by the app developer. If you are coding in react for some basic app, like some basic crud with react using existing backend with Firebase, it almost only require you to learn the some basics of react and Javascript synt… — cttet, 2019-01

Related videos