Q&A with a person who does not have an internal monologue

Channel:PA Struggles · Length:11:23 · Published:2020-02-01 · Views:9730655

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A student interviews Kirsten Carlson, who does not have an internal monologue, and she answers questions about how she thinks. The video grew out of a viral article about people lacking inner speech.

Why HN recommends it

HN refers to it as a vivid first-person account of anendophasia whenever inner monologues come up.

I never miss a chance to reference this video. — HN, 2025

Neuroscience & the brain · Psychology & human behavior · Consciousness & cognition

Subtitles (excerpt)

a few days ago I found out that not everyone has an internal monologue so what I mean by that is like they can't hear their thoughts which I didn't believe to be true until I asked someone and they said that if they physically wanted to say something in their head they'd have to say it out loud like they couldn't do it they don't have that voice that I thought everyone had so it blew my mind and I wrote an article about how it ruined my day and a bunch of people read it and came at me with all these questions that I'm not capable of answering because I can't even wrap my head around it so I decided to do a Q&A with someone that doesn't have this internal monologue so hopefully she could answer your questions because I still can't function here we go all right so I found out a few days ago that not everyone has the ability to speak in their brain and the first person that I asked if they could do it was hurt and turns out she can't so I asked a bunch of people to ask me questions so I could ask her so she could try to make light of this wild situation so like if you looked like I could look at myself in the mirror talk right in my head without opening my mouth you physically can't do that and what

On Hacker News

I never miss a chance to reference this video. A woman vividly describes he experience of not having an inner monologue: [VIDEO] — hackinthebochs, 2025-06
I have one suggestion to make to Marco Giancotti. Please read all of Oliver Sacks books. They will help you clarify your situation a lot due to some case studies he has mentioned in his books. Related : People with no internal monologue [VIDEO] [LINK] — cantor_S_drug, 2025-06
I get that you are in disbelief, but this is actually a thing. Numerous testimonies are unambiguous, such as this one: [VIDEO] Like, the interviewee is able to read extremely fast ("superhuman", according to the interviewer), as a consequence to the absence of inner speech. This kind of details eliminate the possibility of the uncertainties you suggested. — henearkr, 2020-09
Also interesting to note that a good portion of people lack an internal monologue. This interview made the rounds a while back: [VIDEO] — jengleton, 2020-07
Imagine not having a voice in your head. How are you gonna do rubber duck debugging within your head? [VIDEO] — jumping_frog, 2024-10

Related videos