RSA ANIMATE: Smile or Die

Channel:Royal Society of Arts · Length:10:23 · Published:2010-03-17 · Views:2529421

Watch on YouTube

Summary

An RSA Animate drawing of Barbara Ehrenreich's talk on the darker side of positive thinking. It argues that forced positivity in culture, work and policy can be harmful and played a part in the financial crisis.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as a go-to short critique of mandatory positivity in workplaces, startups and corporate culture.

I strongly recommend you to watch Smile or Die, a talk by Barbara Ehrenreich. — HN, 2014

Macroeconomics & financial crises · Social issues & culture · Psychology & human behavior

Subtitles (excerpt)

Within a few years, I began to encounter the same ideology of positive thinking being applied to people who were downsized from the corporate world. White collar middle level people being sent to um support groups or networking groups. There all kinds of names for these things where the message was, hey, it's not bad to be laid off. It's actually a good thing. Uh it's actually an opportunity. It's a growth opportunity and you will come out of it much better. And if you want to come out of it all, of course, you better work on your attitude because the key to getting a job in today's corporate world is not knowing things or having skills or experience, but having a positive attitude. Somebody who's in a an absolute low point in their lives, and certainly losing a job can be that, and just tell them it's nothing wrong, you know, just put, you know, put on a smiley face and get on with it. Mhm. Don't complain whatever you do. So then I be I I began to see a pattern and find it in more and more aspects of um American life. Uh this kind of mandatory optimism and cheerfulness. One area where it is very strongly concentrated now and has been for some years is the corporate world, the workplace, where the idea has been, yes

On Hacker News

As a writer of critical comments of "hacker" school, I think this is typical of the times. If you call out somebody you are dismissed as a debbie-downer, cynical asshat, or other things like that. This comes from a culture now dominated by PR/marketing/sales, getting crazier by the growing viral marketing and astroturfing craze. I strongly recommend you to watch Smile or Die, a talk by Barbara Eh… — alecco, 2014-12
I disagree. The reason why we are often too eager to dismiss is because kindness takes effort. Empathy, and certainly sympathy, is hard work. We get lazy, we become exhausted and our reactions become snappy. Almost always the "dry your eyes" advice is inappropriate and insensitive. And it never really achieves its intended objective. I'm not saying we should all participate in crying orgies whene… — ak39, 2012-12
My issue wasn't with the "retarded" line, actually; I was more concerned by this: "If someone says something negative about your project in an unreasonable way, don’t take it to heart. There’s something good in every project (it’s open source, it already has one thing going for it), no single project is complete crap, keep the good things and learn from the criticism. All this boils down to basic… — MostAwesomeDude, 2011-07
> based on their facial expression Phrenology is still pseudo=scientific bullshit even when the calipers[1] are replaced with an "AI" black box of software. > Just need software that punishes employees who aren't happy enough at work, then we'll have a proper nightmare. "RSA ANIMATE: Smile or Die"[2] [1] [LINK] [2] [VIDEO] — pdkl95, 2022-05
> wage laborers are forced to wear a mask of positivity RSA Animate made a short animation about how a culture of forced positivity in white color jobs, and how it contributed to the late-2000s financial meltdown. "Smile or Die" [VIDEO] — pdkl95, 2019-05

Related videos