Why guitarists USED TO play more in tune! (Microtonal Frets)

Channel:Brandon Acker · Length:15:15 · Published:2022-07-20 · Views:320184

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Classical guitarist Brandon Acker shows how guitars with tied-on gut frets, as used 300 years ago, can play more in tune than modern fixed metal frets. He demonstrates microtonal and meantone tunings on a guitar with movable frets.

Why HN recommends it

Pointed to in tuning and temperament threads as an audible demonstration of how meantone differs from equal temperament.

Brandon Acker gives a wonderful overview on the classical guitar — HN, 2026

Music performance & songs · Music theory, synthesis & production

Subtitles (excerpt)

For me the difference playing it is so surreal. It's so resonant. I love that sound. Ah, it's so satisfying. Hey friends. I'm here today at the beautiful showroom of Marshall Brune the fantastic guitar luthier. We're conducting a really fun experiment. Uh, so I am holding the first as far as I know first ever classical guitar modern classical guitar strung uh or fretted I should say with gut frets just like a lute or a baroque guitar would have been. This is a fun experiment that we decided to do and we made a whole video about doing this which you can check out here. And while I'm here I couldn't resist the opportunity to teach you all about one of the most fascinating topics in music theory that I'm aware which is called temperaments or alternate historical tuning systems. Now that this classical guitar has gut frets we can actually move them to tune in these adjusted uh temperaments. So I'm going to play some classical guitar pieces that you probably only ever heard in equal temperament and we're going to see how it sounds. Now before we take these gut frets and start sliding them around to explore some historical temperaments just a quick little history lesson about what are temperaments in the first place.

On Hacker News

I'd just say I'm playing microtonal music[1][2] and not worry about it. Jokes aside, great read. Always so satisfying when the predictions match experiment. [1]: [LINK] (for the latest craze in microtonal music) [2]: [VIDEO] (for a more informative and historical video) — magicalhippo, 2026-03
If anyone wants to hear the practical effects of a 1/4 comma meantone temperament compared to an equal temperament, Brandon Acker gives a wonderful overview on the classical guitar: [VIDEO] — mbo, 2026-02
Guitarist might find three videos recently posted to classical guitarist and lutist Brandon Acker's YouTube channel interesting. Lutes and early guitars (before around 1800) did not have metal frets. Instead they used pieces of string tied around the neck. They did this because the strings were very expensive, with a set of strings for a lute often costing more than the rest of the lute, and stri… — tzs, 2022-08
An interesting option for fretted instruments is to build it with 12 regular frets per octave, and then add temporary extra frets if you want to make specific notes more in tune for the key you are in. This was common for lute players in the Renaissance and Baroque periods. Lute frets were usually made of the same material as strings and were tied on around the neck, so adding an extra full width… — tzs, 2026-02
Lutes and other fretted instruments in western music back in the renaissance used tied on frets. Each fret was a piece of string tied in a loop around the neck. This meant it was relatively easy to change the position of frets if you wanted to try different temperaments. They could also take small pieces of string and glue them on, so at some places on some strings have an extra option, so that s… — tzs, 2024-04

Related videos