Unity DOTS vs Handbuilt: Sample Project

Channel:Nick Caston · Length:27:56 · Published:2019-12-18 · Views:686855

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Nick Caston compares Unity's sample ECS/DOTS project (AngryBots) with his own from-scratch C++ and OpenGL clone. He benchmarks performance and discusses the effort involved in each approach.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as concrete data in game engine debates, showing a custom engine far outperforming Unity at several times the effort.

A custom 3D engine performs immensely better than a comparable Unity project, but it took the author 3 to 4 times the effort. — HN, 2021

Software performance & optimization · Game programming & engines

Subtitles (excerpt)

Hey so recently I've been working on a little project in the world of game development and I thought the results were pretty interesting and I figured out I'd share with anyone who was interested so in the world of game development we have these game engines which a tool that you can use which try to streamline order of game development and take care of a lot of things that are common to many games so for example they'll help you deal with your physics and lighting animation audio handling their user input and also helping you launch to multiple platforms so you can develop your game once and with hopefully minimal changes you can add that same game right on on Windows and you know Xbox or what-have-you but there's a common question that comes up in game development very very common question which is do I do I really need a game engine or can I just build this game myself and the classic answer to this is yeah you can like you can build it yourself you know get better performance and you have more control over your project but it's usually not worth the extra effort and that sounds pretty reasonable right like I just listed off a whole bunch of features that the game engine kind of takes care of for you but I

On Hacker News

A great demonstration of how unity is bloated: [VIDEO] Unity is targeting students and gamedev wannabees. You don't make a game with a framework. Programming is not simple. Same debate of framework vs libraries. I'm even against Godot, which you cannot even use as a rendering library. You end up being too dependent on those platforms and all their assets and plugins. Of course if you intend to ma… — jokoon, 2020-05
If one doesn't understand how a game works, a framework is not going to help. This person will probably shoot himself in the foot. Here is a good video about benchmarking unity [VIDEO] — jokoon, 2020-01
> ... it greatly decreases your time-to-market to do things in a straightforward way ... I'd actually like to link the YouTube channel of a person who is writing their own game engine and game at the same time: [LINK] You can see how using Godot, Unity or Unreal (or most other engines) would have been much faster in regards to time to market. Similar differences show up when you try to build the … — KronisLV, 2021-11
Let's not guess and simply checkout a fair comparison, like this gentleman did: [VIDEO] From his perspective as an experienced developer, it took 3.4x more effort to implement a very basic project versus using a fully featured engine. And that's ignoring the editor part, not to forget. I'd call a factor of 3.4 quite significant. In more general terms, it's the difference between actually finishin… — qayxc, 2021-06
> In many cases, this software doesn't even do anything that is functionally different from 10 or 20 years ago, but it still consumes many more resources I would argue that in most cases the choice is not between fast, optimized and slow, unoptimized software. The choice is between having a functioning program (using a universal, "reasonably" efficient stack) and not having one at all (because th… — ajconway, 2021-06

Related videos