How Facebook is Stealing Billions of Views

Channel:Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · Length:5:02 · Published:2015-11-10 · Views:10044457

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Kurzgesagt argues that Facebook's claimed 8 billion daily video views are inflated by freebooting, meaning re-uploads of creators' videos. It describes how this harms independent creators.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it to explain freebooting, Facebook's inflated view metrics and why Content ID matters for small creators.

This video changed my opinion on Content ID when I saw it last year — HN, 2016

Internet culture & memes · Tech industry & business models · Media, journalism & propaganda

Subtitles (excerpt)

A few days ago Facebook proudly announced that they'd achieved eight billion video views a day. That's really impressive, until you learn that in the first quarter of 2015, seven hundred and twenty-five of the 1000 most-viewed videos on Facebook were stolen, amassing a total of 17 billion views. Sites and content aggregators steal videos from YouTube to go viral on Facebook. These videos go viral because Facebook is cheating. They rig their algorithms so that videos uploaded into their player are preferred to YouTube links, because users should be kept as long as possible on the site so Facebook can show them as many ads as possible. This is after all their business model. But it also cheats when it comes to views. A view is counted after three seconds even if the video is muted. Which means that because of autoplay, if you scroll through your timeline slowly enough, you count as a viewer. That means engagement is terrible, compared to Youtube views, Facebook views plummet after a few seconds, because most views are not real. But large numbers are impressive, so Facebook keeps pretending. While this forced virality is weird, the real problem is the so called "Freebooting", the stealing of videos. Since Facebook prefers its own player,

On Hacker News

While you're right that Google's implementation of Content ID doesn't handle fair use well, Content ID is critical for indie creators. Facebook's lack of protections lead to tons of lost revenue for them (and for indies, it matters!). This video changed my opinion on Content ID when I saw it last year: [VIDEO] — rryan, 2016-02
A lot of European media sees their content stolen and re-uploaded by anonymous users on YT, FB, etc... FB in particular have not responded to this and thus content creators lose a lot of views and money. This video sums it up nicely: [VIDEO] — apexalpha, 2019-03
[VIDEO] This does a very good job of explaining how small content creators are practically powerless now on the web in terms of protecting their content being stolen. — apexalpha, 2018-12
This is not new, and I've spoken about this here before. Facebook used fraudulent methods to artificially inflate their view counts, and pedelled those fake and grossly exagerrated #s for "eyeballs" to the unsuspecting advertizers. "How Facebook is Stealing Billions of Views" - Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell exposed this with detailed analysis and evidence. Watch it here => [VIDEO] I contracted with … — sean_patel, 2016-11
"How Facebook is Stealing Billions of Views" - Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell exposed this with detailed analysis and evidence. Watch it here => [VIDEO] This is neither a bug nor a "mistake". It's straight up fraud. Fraud because Facebook uses these false #s to prove to their advertizing clients that they are getting a HUGE ROI, when they really aren't. Also the investors and analysts bump up their r… — sean_patel, 2016-09

Related videos