The Unreasonable Efficiency of Black Holes

Channel:minutephysics · Length:6:22 · Published:2017-12-31 · Views:4495606

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Minutephysics compares how efficiently different processes convert mass to energy per E=mc^2, from fire and fission to fusion, antimatter and black holes, which can convert a large fraction of mass to energy.

Why HN recommends it

Linked as a quick, clear primer when black hole energy and efficiency come up.

For readers who want some quick info — HN, 2020

Fundamental physics · Cosmology & astrophysics

Subtitles (excerpt)

E=mc^2, the most famous equation in the world, describes the fact that anything with mass possesses a huge amount of energy, in principle – like, a 5kg cat has enough energy in its mass to power the entire country of Norway for a year – if only the energy could somehow be fully extracted from the cat. But it turns out that efficiently extracting energy from mass is a very hard thing to do. Anti-matter is, of course, the most efficient way of extracting energy from mass since, if you collide a cat with a cat made of anti-matter, 100% of the mass of the cat and anti-cat will be converted into energy (powering Norway for 2 years). But the universe has almost no naturally-occurring anti-matter, so it’s not a practical choice for generating energy, since you’d first have to use a lot of energy to make a large mass of antimatter. Since we can't use antimatter, there are basically three options left to us: chemical reactions, nuclear reactions, and gravitational reactions - aka stuff getting pulled together by gravity, like matter falling into black holes. Chemical reactions, for example, are so bad at extracting energy from mass that we don’t even think about what they’re doing as converting mass to energy (even though it is).

On Hacker News

Well, that very nearly is the method of power generation. It would presumably be paired with some sort of Dyson sphere around the white dwarf. (Remember that a "Dyson sphere" isn't necessarily a solid shell, but just some configuration of matter where no matter which direction the energy goes it is intercepted by something.) You may also enjoy: [VIDEO] which is a minutephysics on black hole power… — jerf, 2021-10
I don’t see why it’s unbelievable. High mass energy conversion is one of the least crazy things about black holes imo. For readers who want some quick info: [VIDEO] This PBS SpaceTime video doesn’t talk about the practical uses of Kugelblitzes, but it isn’t a big leap from understanding what they are to how to get energy out of them. Hawking radiation rate increases as schwarzschild radius decrea… — willis936, 2020-05
> minus a few percent to gravitational waves They actually convert up to 42% of their mass into energy, mostly radiation [VIDEO] — pantalaimon, 2025-07

Related videos