I was asked to keep this confidential

Channel:Sabine Hossenfelder · Length:9:42 · Published:2025-02-15 · Views:3140642

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Sabine Hossenfelder reads a confidential email and uses it to explain her worries about academia and incentives in theoretical physics research. She ties it to her earlier Nature Physics comment on research quality.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in threads about science funding and trust in research as an angry insider critique of academic incentives, though some commenters doubt it.

Fundamental physics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

I want to read you an email that I was asked to keep confidential. I’ve been thinking about this for a long time. But I now believe that reading it to you will go some way to explain why I am worried about the status of scientific research, generally, but especially in the foundations of physics. I received this email about 7 years ago after I published a comment in Nature Physics titled “Science needs reason to be trusted”. In it, I explained how I lost trust in scientific self-correction after I realized how much of what is published in the foundations of physics is nonsense and continues to be nonsense. This email came from someone who I’ve met a few times but don’t know in any depth, and who, at the time, worked at a top institution in the United States. To honour the request of confidentiality, I have removed some details. “Hi Sabine, I am [….], if you remember me. I am not using my work email—the topic is a bit delicate, and I hope that our conversation will remain confidential. I am contacting you regarding your recent paper in Nature which made a lot of noise. First of all, congratulations on a nice paper, if you wanted to attract attention, you managed to do this. Actually, I would like to ask you next time think not only about short-term

On Hacker News

[VIDEO] Sabine highlights the problem with scientific funding in this video and it should be required watching before posting on this thread. Reform is needed. Some good will be tossed with a lot of bad. Its a cycle, a pendulum, and it will eventually tip to excess again sometime in the future. For now... fixing what is broken ought to be the priority. — howmayiannoyyou, 2025-05
It surprises me that some obvious clues to treatment are passed over as I guess they don't fit the politics? Like >A team of researchers in Jerusalem, he says, decided to look at patients who survived bladder cancer and compare dementia prevalence among patients treated with BCG and those who weren’t. “Do they differ in the rate at which they get Alzheimer’s disease?” The answer is yes – the BCG … — tim333, 2025-02
Sabine Hossenfelder: We now live in the grip of post-factualism would seem naturally repellent to most physicists. But in championing theory without demanding empirical evidence, we're guilty of ignoring the facts ourselves. Original paper URL: [LINK] Accessible URL: [LINK] YouTube Video by the Author: [VIDEO] — waonderer, 2025-02
Just yesterday I watched a video by a disgruntled former academic physicist about the state of modern physics research. [0] Not sure of its credence, I don't really understand physics. In the fields I do have a bit of understanding, there does seem to be an amazing amount of fluff and bloat, but also still a significant amount of good and useful knowledge creation. The bloat isn't really surprisi… — bakuninsbart, 2025-02
It's weird that you'd guess (wrong) that I'm an "LLM bull", then start generalizing the actions of this supposed group. Hallucinations are a problem, no news value there. Sabine seems not to be able to get value out of LLMs, and concludes that they aren't useful. The logic is not exactly impressive. It's a tool. It can be useful, it doesn't always work. Some people claim it's better than it is, s… — mollerhoj, 2025-03

Related videos