Every Melody Has Been Copyrighted (and they're all on this hard drive)
Channel:Adam Neely · Length:10:32 · Published:2020-02-10 · Views:1769802
Summary
Adam Neely interviews Damien Riehl and Noah Rubin about their project to generate and copyright every possible melody as MIDI. The video explains their reasoning and how it bears on music copyright lawsuits.
Why HN recommends it
It is the go-to explainer whenever HN discusses brute-forcing melodies, copyright, or AI-generated content, since it features the project's creators.
Strongly recommend watching that video! Excellent info. — HN, 2020
Law, policing & justice · Music theory, synthesis & production
Subtitles (excerpt)
this has the entirety of almost everything so this is a this is 2.6 terabytes and compressed in a tarball and so are they saved as MIDI or they say of Dez's MIDI okay so recently I saw a TED talk where a couple of guys seem to have generated every possible melody or at least every melody that might be sued over in a court of law and by saving those melodies to a harddrive they have affixed them to a physical medium which is all that's necessary to copyright them in other words in theory anyway they have copyrighted every possible melody very interesting I recently got a chance to sit down with them and talk about how they did it and why they did it I'm Damian real I'm a lawyer been a lawyer since 2002 I also been coding since 1985 also musician I have a Bachelors of Science in music education my name is Noah Rubin and I'm Damian's collaborator on this project so Noah and I were on a cybersecurity engagement we were talking about this idea of brute forcing music and I said no I'm do you think you might be able to brute force much like a password could you also brute force melodies he's like yeah that's a relatively easy technical problem we were having drinks one night he was like you know we had talked about this a little
On Hacker News
At the very beginning of this excellent interview [VIDEO] that I found in the comments here, they explain this. Apparently, for this to work, they have to "affix them to a physical medium". Strongly recommend watching that video! Excellent info. — willvarfar, 2020-02
This[0] is a video by Adam Neely, who frequently talks about the cluster f*ck that is copyright law with regards to music, interviewing two guys having done this (within some constraints). This[1] is the website linking to the dataset and code that was used to generate it. [0] [VIDEO] [1] [LINK] — nonstickcoating, 2022-05
If someone automates music creation in the popular styles and then automates submitting it for copyright protection, then in not so distant future creation of any music will be illegal, as every nice sounding melody will be claimed. In a way this is what large labels do. They release a ton of similar sounding music just for that reason. I think the patent trolling equivalent in music world has no… — varispeed, 2021-04
Those are precisely the objections I'd raised with the Damien Rhiel (submitted via email, no response). Additionally there's the problem of releasing the works to the public domain. As discussed a couple of weeks ago when the 2016 billion-dollar infringement lawsuit against Getty Images was attempted ... and thrown out of court ... the act of putting works in the public domain also extinguishes, … — dredmorbius, 2020-02
Damien Riehl and Noah Rubin have all the melodies on a hard drive. (More info in this Adam Neely video: [VIDEO] and the TED talk linked in a nearby comment.) So depending on a court's kinda arbitrary definition of creativity on any given day, all of them may or may not be copyrighted already. An infringement being accidental also doesn't seem to stop copyright holders from successfully suing peop… — an_ko, 2022-12
Related videos
- Frank Abagnale | Catch Me If You Can | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:03:19
- Lexical Scanning in Go - Rob Pike · GoogleFOSSSydney · 51:17
- Where in the world is it easiest to get rich? | Harald Eia | TEDxOslo · TEDx Talks · 15:41
- Introduction: The Chemical History of a Candle by Michael Faraday (1/6) · engineerguy · 3:19
- Do Chairs Exist? · Vsauce · 37:53
- The Perfect Sourdough Pizza (Bread Porn) · LifebyMikeG · 6:46
- The GUI should be better. A lot better. · Accursed Farms · 1:17:21
- Mike Monteiro - "Fuck you pay me" (PT Br) · Montalvo Machado · 38:40
- Mastering the Vim Language · thoughtbot · 36:19
- College Lecture Series - Neil Postman - "The Surrender of Culture to Technology" · College of DuPage · 1:25:11
- The Most IMPORTANT Video You'll Ever See (part 1 of 8) · wonderingmind42 · 9:17
- The Disaster That Changed Engineering: The Hyatt Regency Collapse · Tom Scott · 4:20
- re:publica 2015 - Aral Balkan: Beyond The Camera Panopticon · re:publica · 1:03:13
- The Secret History of Silicon Valley · Google TechTalks · 56:32
- Music Theory and White Supremacy · Adam Neely · 44:01
- Don't Talk to the Police · Regent University School of Law · 46:38