Both Sides - SMBC Theater

Channel:The Theater · Length:3:49 · Published:2010-01-31 · Views:261154

Watch on YouTube

Summary

An SMBC Theater sketch in which JP Nickel presents 'both sides' on every issue, satirizing false balance in news coverage.

Why HN recommends it

Brought up as a joke when threads touch on false balance, media platforming or both-sides debates.

Media, journalism & propaganda · Satire & parody

Subtitles (excerpt)

JP Nickel here. It's time for both sides. No matter what the issue, we bring you both sides of the argument. First up from Caltech, biologist Dr. Smith debates evolution with Dr. Cameron from the Christ wrote a dinosaur and I have pictures institute. Wait, what? Thank you, JP. Now, Dr. Cameron, I understand you have pictures of Christ riding a dinosaur. Oh yeah, the fossil record is explicit. Man and dinosaur were not contemporary. But Dr. Cameron does have pictures. Yes. Uh but but you can't see them. That would explain why we don't see them. But they turn invisible when you look for them. Fair point. Now, Dr. Smith, you believe in evolution. Yes. I don't believe. It is fact. There are millions of fossils, genetic evidence, and the recent Lensky bacteria experiment. Dr. Cameron. That's not an argument. She's just I don't think this argument will be solved anytime soon. But that's why we bring you both sides. There's an ongoing debate over whether to trust Western medicine entirely or to look into so-called alternative medicine. For the West, I have Dr. Burus from the Mayo Clinic. To give you both sides, I have Dr. Leonard Sans, who believes that eyeglasses are a conspiracy against the simpler cure

On Hacker News

I keep seeing the same general sentiment through these types of threads, something in the nature of "if the scientists are so sure they're right, they shouldn't be afraid of mis-information because only their data will stand up to scrutiny." The fact that Rogan has these types of people on his show is not the issue, and just as you say it's fine to interview them. The issue is that he tends to ta… — sfteus, 2022-01
It doesn't have much to do with age. It's the same problem as the "both sides" approach to anything [0] ("my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge"). This inherently just moves the problem to decide who's informed (or equivalently what's the required level of "informedness"). Many jurisdictions routinely suspend people's voting rights. Due process and all. Of course when it comes to giving … — pas, 2020-12
>The problem with giving "both sides" of an issue equal time is that it can legitimize completely indefensible positions And here's the comedy sketch: [VIDEO] — dTal, 2015-08

Related videos