The Banach–Tarski Paradox

Channel:Vsauce · Length:24:13 · Published:2015-08-01 · Views:49185533

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Vsauce's roughly 24 minute explainer on the Banach-Tarski paradox, building from infinity and set theory to the decomposition of a sphere into pieces that form two spheres.

Why HN recommends it

Recommended as an accurate, entertaining on-ramp to set theory and infinity, worth pausing and rewatching.

This vsauce video is actually a really accurate (and entertaining!) introduction to set theory — HN, 2021

Pure mathematics · Recreational & visual math · Logic & formal methods

Subtitles (excerpt)

Hey, Vsauce. Michael here. There's a famous way to seemingly create chocolate out of nothing. Maybe you've seen it before. This chocolate bar is 4 squares by 8 squares, but if you cut it like this and then like this and finally like this you can rearrange the pieces like so and wind up with the same 4 by 8 bar but with a leftover piece, apparently created out of thin air. There's a popular animation of this illusion as well. I call it an illusion because it's just that. Fake. In reality, the final bar is a bit smaller. It contains this much less chocolate. Each square along the cut is shorter than it was in the original, but the cut makes it difficult to notice right away. The animation is extra misleading, because it tries to cover up its deception. The lost height of each square is surreptitiously added in while the piece moves to make it hard to notice. I mean, come on, obviously you cannot cut up a chocolate bar and rearrange the pieces into more than you started with. Or can you? One of the strangest theorems in modern mathematics is the Banach-Tarski paradox. It proves that there is, in fact, a way to take an object and separate it into 5 different pieces. And then, with those five pieces, simply

On Hacker News

Learn set theory! Specifically ordinals (just one formal defintion of a number) This vsauce video is actually a really accurate (and entertaining!) introduction to set theory: [VIDEO] — Aicy, 2021-09
I don't know if this will explain your questions, but years ago I watched this video from Vsauce about this very topic, and IIRC it was explained quite nicely: [VIDEO] — djvdq, 2024-06
[VIDEO] nicely visualizes it. It's an infinite number of infinitely thin filaments from the center of the sphere going outward in every direction. — josephcsible, 2023-01
Note that the OP is about cuts that are nice, cutting polygons into smaller polygons, that could be done using a scissor. The article you linked is about using magical cuts that be non measurable, that look like magical interlocking 2D sponges. They are somewhat like the figures in the gif, but they actually more weird. It's somewhat similar to the Banach–Tarski Paradox. If you like that, I recom… — gus_massa, 2022-11
I agree that most videos in YouTube simplify the problem too much or are just wrong. My recommendations anyway: * Mathologer: " Ramanujan: Making sense of 1+2+3+... = -1/12 and Co. " [LINK] * Vsauce: " The Banach–Tarski Paradox " [VIDEO] Each one is like half an hour long, but you may need to pause them and rewatch them a few times to understand the details. — gus_massa, 2022-04

Related videos