Consciousness in Artificial Intelligence | John Searle | Talks at Google

Channel:Talks at Google · Length:1:10:37 · Published:2015-12-04 · Views:483069

Watch on YouTube

Summary

John Searle's Talk at Google on consciousness and artificial intelligence, hosted by Google's Singularity Network. He presents his philosophy of mind and Chinese room argument that computation is syntactic and cannot capture semantics.

Why HN recommends it

Used as a source for Searle's own argument in Chinese room discussions, though some find nothing new in it.

He explains this in the google video very well — HN, 2016

AI & data (other) · Consciousness & cognition · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

JOHN BRACAGLIA: My name is John Bacaglia. And I'm a Googler working in YouTube operations. I also lead a group called the Singularity Network, an internal organization focused on discussions and rationality in artificial intelligence. I'm pleased to be here today with Mr. John Searle. As a brief introduction, John Searle is the Slusser Professor of Philosophy at the University of California-Berkeley. He is widely noted for his contributions to the philosophy of language, philosophy of mind, and social philosophy. John has received the Jean Nicod Prize, the National Humanities Medal in the Mind and Brain prize for his work. Among his noble concepts is the Chinese room argument against strong artificial intelligence. John Searle, everyone. [APPLAUSE] JOHN SEARLE: Thank you Thank you. Many thanks. It's great to be back at Google. It is a university outside of a university. And sometimes, I think, this is what a university ought really to look like. Anyway, it's just terrific to be here. And I'm going to talk about some-- well, I'm going to talk about a whole lot of stuff. But, basically, I want to start with talking about the significance of technological advances. And America, especially, but everybody, really,

On Hacker News

Philosophy is not some sort of church where everyone praise some emotionally agreed upon idea... You seems to be turning this into some sort of us vs. them game based on your faulty projections, so I hope to stop here. (Btw, If you are getting your ideas about philosophy from popular youtube channels like [LINK] or [LINK] , maybe I can understand why you have such misunderstandings) ----------- I… — 3498rtigcufk, 2017-03
I was not trying to connect rule 110 to Searle's argument per se, but rather to the critique of Searle's argument. Namely, that criticisms of the lookup table are not criticisms of Searle's argument or the point he makes. a C++ program, brainf k, a CA, a one instruction set computer, or whatever computational process is used doesn't matter. The lookup table is just one component of the Rooms oper… — makebelieve, 2016-01
Searle would have us interpret this as the company taking the intelligence of the humans, refining and repackaging it. [VIDEO] — stcredzero, 2016-03
Your points are all good. But they have nothing to do with meaning, or with semantics. Cellular automata are lookup tables, and Wolfram and others proved some cellular automata rules are Turing complete computers. [LINK] My point was merely about the equivalence of computational mechanisms, not about lookup tables per se. And by corollary, that the computational complexity is equivalent regardles… — makebelieve, 2016-01
There isn't much new here. Skip ahead to the first audience question from Ray Kurzweil ( [VIDEO] ). Kurzweil, in summary, asks "You say that a machine manipulating symbols can't have consciousness. Why is this different than consciousness arising neurons manipulating neurotransmitter concentrations?" Searle gives a non-answer: "My dog has consciousness because I can look at it and conclude that i… — bhickey, 2015-12

Related videos