Jaron Lanier – Who is Civilization for? (+ Q&A with Ulrich Kelber) Willy Brandt Lecture 2018

Channel:Bundeskanzler-Willy-Brandt-Stiftung · Length:1:23:44 · Published:2018-12-11 · Views:151872

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Jaron Lanier delivers the 2018 Willy Brandt Lecture in Berlin on who civilization is for, covering data, AI, tech platforms and the economics of who benefits, followed by a Q&A with Germany's data protection commissioner Ulrich Kelber.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it for Lanier's ideas on the circle of empathy and paying people whose data and work train AI.

The best proposal I’ve heard to deal with the societal/economic problems this sort of A.I. poses were made by Jaron Lanier — HN, 2022

Privacy, surveillance & cybercrime · Tech industry & business models · Futurism & technology and society

Subtitles (excerpt)

We say who is civilization for? And of course, I think most people would immediately have an answer. I think most people would say it should benefit human beings. It should sustain the human project. It should benefit the overall biosphere, the ecosystem of the Earth so that this all continues. That's probably who civilization is for but it's never quite that simple. When I was much younger, I came up with an image to help me think about who the beneficiary is of our activities, whether we're engineers or writers or anything else and I call this the circle of empathy. By the way, the term empathy had its origins in the a circle of psychologists and poets in Germany about a century ago and the original use of the term was essentially imagining what virtual reality would be like someday. In the original use of the term, there was an example given that somebody might be able to imagine themselves as a leaf or as a mountain and that as people could exercise their imagination to become different parts of reality, that that would also help them appreciate each other and develop a sympathy for one another's different positions. It was a very charming idea but this notion of a radical transformation itself, (phone ringing) Wait. That horrible technology.

On Hacker News

The best proposal I’ve heard to deal with the societal/economic problems this sort of A.I. poses were made by Jaron Lanier: [VIDEO] …I can see why his proposals of providing (micro-)compensation to people whose tremendous efforts end up being mined by these algorithms would not be popular with researchers/companies who stand to benefit vastly (…presumably including the investors who own this site… — vghfgk1000, 2022-10
First I wanted to say I'm not trying to guilt trip you or anything, I admit I wrote my response quickly and didn't think it would attract this much attention. So just wanted to let you know I value your views and am not trying to put you down! > That doesn't really answer the question though. If knowingly making society worse were the standard for feeling shame, I think I'd be too depressed and s… — animal_spirits, 2021-12
About Minsky being too optimistic: "I would tell Marvin this whole AI thing is just horrible. Why are we doing it? And he would say it will be effective for getting our grants, so shut up and just play along and in fact, it was true. It was very good for getting grants back in the early days, in the 70's was when I started at this, you would go to a grant making organization such as the Defense D… — zone411, 2024-03

Related videos