What If Dark Matter Is Just Black Holes?

Channel:PBS Space Time · Length:12:21 · Published:2021-04-13 · Views:989095

Watch on YouTube

Summary

PBS Space Time asks whether dark matter could be made of primordial black holes. It walks through the observational constraints that limit this idea.

Why HN recommends it

HN people link it in dark matter and black hole threads as a clear summary of why black holes alone are unlikely to explain dark matter.

Matt demonstrates point by point that there aren't enough black holes to be dark matter for several reasons/types — HN, 2024

Quantum physics · Cosmology & astrophysics

Subtitles (excerpt)

It may be that for every star in the universe there are billions of microscopic black holes streaming through the solar system, the planet, even our bodies every second. Sounds horrible - but hey, at least we’d have explained dark matter. 80% of the mass of our universe is completely invisible to us - its existence only revealed through its immense gravitational influence. This is dark matter, and it is one of the universe’s most perplexing mysteries. These days most dark matter hunters are trying to hypothesize or detect exotic new particles to explain the stuff - and we recently discussed some of the possibilities for brand new particle physics that might explain dark matter. Others are trying to find holes in Einstein’s theory of gravity - the general theory of relativity - that might explain dark matter’s influence without the need for actual matter. But there is one explanation that may require no new physics whatsoever - an explanation that is so bafflingly simple it almost feels overlooked. What if dark matter is just black holes? These hyper-dense holes in the fabric of spacetime seem to be great dark matter candidates - being so black and holey and all. As we’ve discussed many times before, black

On Hacker News

This PBS Spacetime video pours some cold water on the black holes as dark matter hypothesis: [VIDEO] It’s 4 years old; I don’t know if this JWST finding changes anything. I do know we have finally found some (one?) intermediate-mass black holes in the interim, but I don’t know if that changes it either. The possibility it leaves open for “Planck relics” is interestingly exotic — jraines, 2025-07
That was my first thought too. A cursory search indicates we would see a lot more gravitational lensing in our observations if that was the case. Found a couple of videos on it too [VIDEO] [LINK] — nabakin, 2025-04
(sorry only available on youtube, they no longer seem to mirror on pbs.org ) If you aren't familiar with Matt, yes he is at least 50% Neanderthal but also brilliant, lol btw I owe @api an apology, apparently black holes could indeed be dark matter, I missed this one from Matt a few years ago (or forgot the lesson) [VIDEO] (actually by the end of that video Matt demonstrates point by point that th… — ck2, 2024-09
This was covered by PBS spacetime: [VIDEO] Still possible, but increasingly unlikely due to the narrowing size range in which these black holes are allowed to exist in. — irjustin, 2024-06
Got it. The reference is great, the only final addendum I wanted to mention was whether a neutron stars densities would stop a black hole in its tracks since the paper only talks about the black hole already having been there. (At least to remove the amateur recollection of mine from the reference link, the mention of this possibility happens in the video at 6:18 [VIDEO] ) and here’s them talking… — ramraj07, 2022-04

Related videos