Gimbal UFO - A New Analysis

Channel:Mick West · Length:21:25 · Published:2022-03-14 · Views:208274

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Mick West analyzes the Navy's Gimbal UFO video and gives four checkable observations suggesting it is an infrared glare that appears to rotate because the camera rotates while tracking. He argues the object is likely a hot craft hidden behind the glare.

Why HN recommends it

Pointed to as the clearest, evidence-based debunk of the Gimbal footage, and a model of how to analyze such claims.

The summary video is concise and only 20 minutes long. I challenge you to watch all of it and respond specifically. — HN, 2023

Military history & warfare · Media, journalism & propaganda · Religion, belief & skepticism

Subtitles (excerpt)

in this video i'm going to demonstrate four observables four things that you can verify yourself that demonstrate that the gimbal ufo video almost certainly shows a glare that hides the actual object and that the shape of the glare is only rotating because the camera is rotating briefly the four observables are one no rotation when banking the shape does not rotate when the jet banks everything else rotates the shape does not two bumps before rotation when the shape does rotate there's a bump right at the start sometimes a fraction of a second before three rotating patterns when the shape rotates there's a matching rotation of light patterns across the entire image four derotation matches the rotation of the shape matches exactly the amount of d rotation needed for tracking the target the first three are simple observations they don't need any math to see their implications just an understanding of the camera system the last one does require math but i can also demonstrate it with a simulation so you can see the math matches the physical reality before we get into the four observables we need to understand what is going on what are we looking at and how is it filmed the gimbal ufo video is the poster child of modern ufo

On Hacker News

> So you're telling me, some random game developer was more competent than the US military guys who literally are hired for such analysis? In the case of the most-cited "Gimbal" video, all the military has officially said is they can't determine for sure what the object the glare shown in the video is from. But everyone already agrees on that point. No one can tell from the video whether the glar… — mrandish, 2023-06
an interesting youtube comment: "2:42 Check out the readout on the bottom right . One of the numbers is the target height above terrain - and after it's hit that goes down from 86 to 59 over about 6 seconds before the video cuts off. So after being hit the object isn't continuing on course, it's falling at an increasingly fast rate. The video was sent to Rep. Eric Burlison with no chain of custod… — trenchpilgrim, 2025-09
How is the GIMBAL video still listed as "unresolved"? Mick West's analysis seems to explain it pretty thoroughly: [VIDEO] At the very least I would have hoped that there would be more than just a link to the video, and a section saying that some convincing explanations have been proposed. Right now it looks like on the first day it was released, as if this case was still just as mysterious. — thamer, 2023-09
After taking the pilots' accounts on face value, this analysis gave me new insight: [VIDEO] The pilots claim they saw a flying saucer that was rotating in weird ways, and provide a grainy video that's kind of convincing. The analysis proves it was lens flare. There are additional debunked UAP videos released by the military, including one that is lens bokeh around starlight, which is debunked by … — shrimpx, 2023-06
Tangential, but there's some great analysis and debunks of the video the headline photo is taken from: [VIDEO] Simulation: [LINK] — bragr, 2023-06

Related videos