Jones Act Debate | Center for Maritime Strategy & Heritage Foundation | Containerships & Dirigibles

Channel:What's Going on With Shipping? · Length:43:23 · Published:2023-11-18 · Views:180524

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Sal Mercogliano of What's Going on With Shipping? discusses a debate between the Center for Maritime Strategy and the Heritage Foundation over whether the Jones Act helps or harms American shipping and national security.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends the channel for clear coverage of the history, cabotage rules and debate around the Jones Act.

Nice discussion on the history and future of the Jones Act. — HN, 2024

Business & economics (other) · Law, policing & justice · Ships, submarines & maritime

Subtitles (excerpt)

Today's episode of What's Going On with Shipping. It's time for a Jones Act debate. I'm your host, Sam Magliano. Welcome to today's episode. No, this isn't going to be a Jones Act debate between me and Peter Zion. I know how many of you have requested that, but this is actually a Jones Act debate over at the Center for Maritime Strategy. This is a center that's supported by the US Navy League and specifically this is on their Maritime Operations Center blog. And so they decided to bring in these two people and argue the pro and con of the Jones Act. If you don't know what the Jones Act is, this refers specifically to section 27 of the Merchant Marine Act of 1920. Now the whole act is the Jones Act, but the part that usually gets mentioned is this section which deals with cababotage. And what cababotage is is the movement of good between two US ports. But the requirement is to move goods between US ports, you have to do it on a US flagged, US-built, US-owned, and US crude ship. This has been the rule since 1920, and prior to that, it was the rule since 1817. It's been around for a long, long time. Uh many nations have cab, but not all nations have the the scope of the American cabage. Some countries require, for example, just uh have to be domestically flagged

On Hacker News

> This will never succeed because the economies of scale are nonexistent without dominance in the commercial shipbuilding market. War planners should have pushed to repeal the Jones Act decades ago The US used to subsidize the salaries of US merchant marines on ships (US salaries are higher than Filipino ones) so that there would be a trained population, but that was stopped in the 1980s because … — throw0101c, 2025-02
Nice discussion on the history and future of the Jones Act. Dr. Salvatore R. Mercogliano on the Jones Act Debate | Center for Maritime Strategy & Heritage Foundation | Container ships & Dirigibles [VIDEO] — jakeogh, 2024-01
With deference to What’s Going on With Shipping[1], the Jones Act isn’t really the problem. The entire incentive structure and industry crumbled well after it was enacted. [1] [VIDEO] — npmanor, 2026-03

Related videos