that dark matter video aged like milk

Channel:Angela Collier · Length:1:00:28 · Published:2024-05-24 · Views:406208

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Angela Collier, a physicist, revisits her earlier dark matter video, explaining dark matter as a set of observations rather than a theory and discussing MOND comments.

Why HN recommends it

HN points to her videos as a counterpoint to popular dark matter discussion, framing it as the discrepancy that needs explaining.

these YouTube videos are a nice counterpoint to a lot of popular communication and discussion on dark matter — HN, 2024

Cosmology & astrophysics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

I thought it would be fun to do something a little different today and talk about what a huge failure I am have you ever done something so sincerely so earnestly and you shove it out into the world and half a million people watch it and only 60% of people who watched it like got it which means it was a failure which means it was bad you were trying to communicate an idea and it didn't work how embarrassing for you publicly half a million people is a lot of people yikes so we're coming up on the one-year anniversary of this video and I thought it would be fun to do like an analysis A retrospective an autopsy of like what a failure of science communication this was CU as I said only 60% of people and I'll tell you how I got that number who watched this video understood the video which is of course my fault like I'm trying to communicate an idea and I failed like that was pretty bad 60% is a failing grade like that's embarrassing okay so let's give a quick summary of this video I I had to rewatch it obviously for this video and that was horrible for me but the video itself is fine um the sound is bad it's hard to listen to if you don't have headphones I'm sorry I edit with headphones so I thought it was fine but the video is fine the science in

On Hacker News

Dark Matter is a name for set of observations that aren't explainable with currently accepted cosmological theory. There are many possible ideas of how Dark Matter problem can be solved. Why do you think making fun of specific idea of what might be the cause of Dark Matter problem or even the Dark Matter problem itself is problematic? Did suddenly the deficiencies of current state of science beca… — scotty79, 2024-10
If you've got the time, these YouTube videos are a nice counterpoint to a lot of popular communication and discussion on dark matter: Dark matter is not a theory: [LINK] That dark matter video aged like milk: [VIDEO] the tl;dr is that "dark matter" is a bit of a misnomer. (But also a fun name so it's probably here to stay through sheer memetic momentum.) Dark matter is not actually a hypothesized… — bunderbunder, 2024-08
IANAP (physicist) The only the matter portion of the universe is 85% dark matter (26.8% of mass-energy content of the universe). As for the question; I don't think it's right to assume that dark matter really is exotic matter. It's just a set of observations. It's something that behaves like matter (with respect to density scaling) but only seems to interact gravitationally. Some theories posit t… — PartiallyTyped, 2024-06
Let's talk about the article and then dark matter, I guess: > We’ve always been taught that the fundamental constants of nature — like the speed of light or the charge of an electron — are unchanging. But what if they aren’t fixed after all? I mean, sure, what if? Honestly, if you can vary things like gravity, I don't think you need any additional components to explain the dark matter observation… — wrsh07, 2024-10
I also don't know why MOND remains so popular. Angela Collier talks about Dark Matter here: [LINK] And talks more about how often MOND is brought up in comments on her own video: [VIDEO] — ansible, 2024-06

Related videos