Was Roman Concrete Better?
Channel:Practical Engineering · Length:9:34 · Published:2018-10-29 · Views:2657323
Summary
Practical Engineering compares modern concrete with that of the Roman Empire, covering modern techniques like roller compacted concrete and water-reducing admixtures. It explains the tradeoffs of Roman construction versus reinforced concrete.
Why HN recommends it
HN recommends it as a clear, balanced answer to claims that Roman concrete was better than ours.
Here's a good video on the use and tradeoffs of Roman concrete engineering — HN, 2022
Materials science · Civil engineering & construction
Subtitles (excerpt)
The largest unreinforced concrete dome in world is on the Pantheon. It’s not a modern marvel, but rather an ancient Roman temple built almost two thousand years ago. So, if concrete structures from the western Roman Empire can last for thousands of years, why does modern infrastructure look like this after only a couple of decades? Hey I’m Grady and this is Practical Engineering. In today’s episode, we’re taking a look at the factors that affect the design life of concrete. This video is sponsored by Brilliant. More on that later. If you haven’t seen the previous videos in this series about concrete, here’s a quick synopsis. We’ve talked about how concrete’s made, why it often needs reinforcement, and how that reinforcement can sometimes lead to deterioration. Concrete reinforced with steel bars is the foundation of our modern society. The reinforcement is required to give the concrete strength against tensile stress. We use steel as reinforcement because of its strength, its similar thermal behavior, its availability, and low cost. But steel has an important weakness: it rusts. Not only does this corrosion reduce the strength of the reinforcement itself, but its by-product, iron oxide, expands.
On Hacker News
Concrete without rebar lacks tensile strength, and Roman concrete is no different. When using materials with insufficient tensile strength, you're severely restricted in the kinds of structures you can build. That's why Roman buildings used so many domes and arches, and why they were massive . Practical Engineering has a good video about it: [VIDEO] — adwn, 2022-10
> Same goes for roman concrete. We know far more about concrete than the Romans did. We just don't bother to engineer everything to last forever, because that costs money and has little point to it a lot of the time. Yes, some buildings are works of art, but many things just have a function to fulfill, which is often temporary. Nobody is sad that the millions of mass-made soviet residential crapp… — wnevets, 2022-10
Here's a good video on the use and tradeoffs of Roman concrete engineering: [VIDEO] TL;DW: whereas modern construction uses rebar as a way to keep concrete from fracturing under tensile stress, the Romans made their constructions enormous so that the weight of the structure itself would compress the material and keep it from failing from tensile stress. Their monuments weren't built huge just bec… — kibwen, 2022-01
The civil engineering-oriented channel Practical Engineering has a pretty good video on Roman concrete vs. modern. [VIDEO] The primary tldw; is the fact modern concrete uses steel rebar for tensile strength, whereas the Romans relied on architectural techniques to minimize tensile forces on their structures. Steel rebar is the primary route through which concrete deteriorates. — sillyquiet, 2021-10
I agree with your general point that we are in no way inherently superior to our ancestors, but Roman concrete, Damacus steel, and Greek fire are inferior to what we have today to accomplish the same things. Practical Engineering on Roman concrete. The TL;DR is that we are far more advanced. [VIDEO] We do know how to make Damascus steel: [LINK] This fellow says we don't know how to make the histo… — rendall, 2024-11
Related videos
- THE SAGAN SERIES - The Frontier Is Everywhere · Reid Gower · 3:11
- The LED's Challenge to High Pressure Sodium · Technology Connections · 21:39
- The Epic Of Gilgamesh In Sumerian · Peter Pringle · 3:55
- NaN Gates and Flip FLOPS · suckerpinch · 19:07
- Mechanical Computer (All Parts) - Basic Mechanisms In Fire Control Computers · Excelsior10000 · 41:53
- SNES Code Injection -- Flappy Bird in SMW · SethBling · 6:31
- Mars Helicopter (before it went to Mars) · Veritasium · 16:00
- RAT POISON AND BRANDY: THE 1904 ST. LOUIS OLYMPIC MARATHON. · Jon Bois · 21:02
- TRUE Limits Of Humanity – The Final Border We Will Never Cross · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 11:40
- Thinking outside the 10-dimensional box · 3Blue1Brown · 25:13
- 1,000km Cable to the Stars - The Skyhook · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 7:00
- Finding the Missing Memristor - R. Stanley Williams · The Qualcomm Institute · 47:52
- Stroads are Ugly, Expensive, and Dangerous (and they're everywhere) [ST05] · Not Just Bikes · 18:13
- 1. How Buildings Learn - Stewart Brand - 1 of 6 - “Flow” · Stewart Brand · 29:36
- What Really Happened During the Texas Power Grid Outage? · Practical Engineering · 16:47
- Why It Was Almost Impossible to Make the Blue LED · Veritasium · 33:44