Alexander Pope Wrote a 35-Page Takedown of a Historian

Channel:CGP Grey · Length:21:32 · Published:2021-09-09 · Views:10367836

Watch on YouTube

Summary

CGP Grey tells the story of Alexander Pope's long takedown of a historian, Thomas Hearne, framed around the quirks of library books and archival research. It is a funny, digressive video essay about literary feuds and tracking down original sources.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters point to it as a masterpiece of humorous archival detective work and a great watch about books and libraries.

Linking the full video because it's a masterpiece — HN, 2022

World history · Documentaries & storytelling · Literature & writing craft

Subtitles (excerpt)

Tada! It's a video about Tiffany! I hope you like it. Psst. Hey, hey. Would you like to know more? Okay great. So listen, I need to tell you about this poem. Come with me behind the scenes where I've been working on this for... I don't even know how long. Take a seat. Get comfortable. It all began with these articles I read saying the name Tiffany is very old, maybe medieval. What a cute and easy video, Past-Grey thought, and it could have been :: it could have been :: if I'd just left things alone, but no, I wanted to read the article sources, which turned out didn't often contain the name Tiffany at all, but rather the ye-olden-name Theophania, or the super-old Theophanu. And like, maybe these medieval ladies called themselves Tiff, but that's just a bit too cute, isn't it? To me it looked like the sort of Lady Godiva story where later writers say a thing happened but there's no evidence from the time that it did, because it's a fairy tale. The kind history is full of once you go looking. [whispering] Don't go looking. So for a while the Tiffany video teetered on the edge of getting binned, but it turned out my Lady Godiva suspicious were wrong when some medieval Tiffany's did turn up to save the project.

On Hacker News

To see this gloriously realised, check out CGP Grey's description of Pope's feud with Thomas Hearne. Linking the full video because it's a masterpiece [VIDEO] — rozab, 2022-09
For a really great video mostly about checking out books from a library watch this: [VIDEO] I found it pretty funny that hundreds of years later he unearthed an old written feud that ended up directly affecting him in a way which caused him to empathize with one of the sides. — fossuser, 2021-12
Very cool. If you're interested in things like this you might wanna checkout CGP Grey's videos on tracking down various stories from books through archives. [VIDEO] — ChrisbyMe, 2025-12
If you enjoyed this, you might also enjoy two videos from CGP Grey: - The Race to Win Staten Island ( [LINK] ) - Someone dead ruined my life... again ( [VIDEO] ) — Macha, 2023-09
> This one’s notable in that it puts an entire passage in quotes, but it turns out the passage was not in Cheung (1983) at all—not on page 8 or anywhere else in that article—it actually came from a collection from 1998 of old Harvard Business School exam questions. One of my pet peeves is the chain of citations that will inevitably spawn from this. No author can be bothered to go find the origina… — lolinder, 2022-10

Related videos