What Really Happened at the Millennium Tower?

Channel:Practical Engineering · Length:13:32 · Published:2021-11-16 · Views:3992630

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Practical Engineering explains why San Francisco's Millennium Tower is sinking and tilting, covering how geology and foundation design (friction piles in the Colma Formation) affect skyscrapers. It also covers the fix being attempted.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters point to it as the well-made, detailed explanation of the Millennium Tower debacle whenever the tower comes up.

Grady also has an excellently made video about the leaning Millennium Tower in SF — HN, 2022

Geology & earth science · Civil engineering & construction

Subtitles (excerpt)

The Millennium Tower is the tallest residential building in San Francisco, with 58 stories above the ground and 419 luxury condominium units. The tower opened to residents in 2009, but even before construction was finished, engineers could tell that the building was slowly sinking into the ground and tilting to one side. How do engineers predict how soils will behave under extreme loading conditions, and what do you do when a skyscraper’s foundation doesn’t perform the way it was designed? Let’s find out. I’m Grady, and this is Practical Engineering. In today’s episode, we’re talking about the Millennium Tower in San Francisco. Skyscrapers are heavy. That might seem self-evident, but it can’t be overstated in a story like this. An average single-story residential home is designed to apply a pressure to the subsurface of maybe 100 pounds per square foot of building footprint. That’s about 5 kilopascals, the pressure at the bottom of a knee-deep pool of water. With its concrete skeleton, the Millennium Tower was designed to impose a load of 11,000 pounds per square foot or 530 kilopascals to its foundation (about 100 times more than an average house). It would be impossible for just the ground

On Hacker News

Here is someone who goes into detail about the Millennium Tower debacle: [VIDEO] In short, shortcuts, or more charitably, miscalculations. They really thought they had enough margin to work with but obviously that wasn’t the case. — mc32, 2023-01
Grady also has an excellently made video about the leaning Millennium Tower in SF and what they’re doing while still trying to fix it. [VIDEO] — dodgerdan, 2022-07
It's been interesting watching this unfold, some good videos around it: Most recent report from engineer mentioned in article to oversight committee: [LINK] (Item 8, around 2 hours in) New Project Aims To Reinforce, Level Out Millennium Tower - [LINK] What Really Happened at the Millennium Tower? - [VIDEO] SF Millennium Tower Tilts Quarter Inch in Four Days - [LINK] Despite Warnings, Repairs on S… — neom, 2022-01

Related videos