Margaret Thatcher - "They'd rather have the poor poorer."
Channel:Excelsior10000 · Length:2:34 · Published:2013-04-08 · Views:285343
Summary
A short clip of Margaret Thatcher in Parliament in 1990 arguing that economic reforms benefited everyone even as the rich-poor gap widened. She says her opponents would rather the poor be poorer if it meant the rich were less rich.
Why HN recommends it
Commenters link it as a shorthand for an argument about inequality, absolute versus relative prosperity, quoting her line in threads about taxes and wealth.
Thatcher had famously summarized the inequality argument here — HN, 2023
Labor, work & inequality · Politics & history (other)
Subtitles (excerpt)
I give way to the honorable gentleman. There is no doubt that the prime minister has in many ways achieved substantial success in the economy. There is there is one statistic that I understand is not however challengeable and that is that over her 11 years the gap between the richest 10% and the poorest 10% in this country has widened substantially. That's right. How can she say at the end of her chapter of British politics that she can justify many people in a constituency such as mine being relatively much poorer, much less well-housed and much less well provided than it was in 1979. Surely she accepts that is not a record that she or any prime minister can be proud of. Mr. Speaker, all levels of income are better off than they were in 1979. But what the honorable member is saying is that he would rather the poor were poorer provided the rich were less rich. That way you will never create the wealth for better social services as we have. And what a policy. Yes, he would rather have the poor poorer provided the rich were left. That is a liberal policy. Yes, it came out. He didn't intend it to, but he did. Way to the I give way to the honorable gentleman. I'm extremely I'm extremely grateful.
On Hacker News
My argument was that in absolute terms, the 1% already pays ~100x more than the median tax payer, which seems pretty close to stating that the median tax payer reaps the benefits of modern civilization essentially for free. Regarding inequality, this can't be the metric for taxation policy. Would you rather the 1% pay all taxes but inequality be 100x worse ? Are you optimizing for a better standa… — utopcell, 2023-01
I'm reminded of Margaret Thatcher's response to this: "He'd rather the poor were poorer, as long as the rich were less rich."[1] Every ethical dollar earned is a byproduct of value creation. Maybe you meant something more like "as long as he's not ripping off his customers," but otherwise that's an odd thing to say in response to someone who makes good money but is still looking for side jobs. [1… — CrazyPyroLinux, 2022-08
[VIDEO] EDIT: I would make my comment more substantial, but Margaret Thatcher made my comment better than I could. — cryptonector, 2019-01
As Margaret Thatcher said:"Socialists would rather have the poor poorer provided the rich were less rich" [VIDEO] — cft, 2016-09
Related videos
- Try to Rule Fairly and You'll Be Overthrown · CGP Grey · 18:13
- What Happened to Horses Is Happening to Us · CGP Grey · 15:00
- London Swallowed a City but Couldn't Digest It. · CGP Grey · 4:47
- Winners Take All | Anand Giridharadas | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:00:56
- The Coming Collapse of the Middle Class with Elizabeth Warren · University of California Television (UCTV) · 57:37
- The UK Is a Country Made of Countries · CGP Grey · 5:14
- America Keeps Rejecting an ID Card It Already Has · CGP Grey · 7:15
- Wealth Inequality in America · politizane · 6:23
- Roblox Pressured Us to Delete Our Video. So We Dug Deeper. · People Make Games · 35:21
- Most Cities Got More Democratic. This One Didn't. · CGP Grey · 5:47
- Immigration, World Poverty and Gumballs · NumbersUSA · 6:08
- The Voting System That's Actually Too Good for Politicians to Allow · CGP Grey · 6:47
- Debate Noam Chomsky & Michel Foucault - On human nature [Subtitled] · withDefiance · 1:10:03
- Democracy at Work: Curing Capitalism | Richard Wolff | Talks at Google · Talks at Google · 1:25:34
- I Tried To Make Something In America (The Smarter Scrubber Experiment) - Smarter Every Day 308 · SmarterEveryDay · 48:53
- Where in the world is it easiest to get rich? | Harald Eia | TEDxOslo · TEDx Talks · 15:41