Daniel Suarez: The kill decision shouldn't belong to a robot
Channel:TED · Length:13:20 · Published:2013-06-13 · Views:78160
Summary
Novelist Daniel Suarez warns in a TED talk about autonomous robotic weapons and drones. He argues that taking the decision to kill out of human hands threatens democratic accountability and calls for a ban.
Why HN recommends it
Plugged repeatedly in AI and drone threads as a concise statement of the dangers of automated weapons.
I often plug Daniel Suarez's great Kill Decision talk and book — HN, 2025
AI safety, AGI & impact · Robotics · Military history & warfare
Subtitles (excerpt)
Translator: Joseph Geni Reviewer: Morton Bast I write fiction sci-fi thrillers, so if I say "killer robots," you'd probably think something like this. But I'm actually not here to talk about fiction. I'm here to talk about very real killer robots, autonomous combat drones. Now, I'm not referring to Predator and Reaper drones, which have a human making targeting decisions. I'm talking about fully autonomous robotic weapons that make lethal decisions about human beings all on their own. There's actually a technical term for this: lethal autonomy. Now, lethally autonomous killer robots would take many forms -- flying, driving, or just lying in wait. And actually, they're very quickly becoming a reality. These are two automatic sniper stations currently deployed in the DMZ between North and South Korea. Both of these machines are capable of automatically identifying a human target and firing on it, the one on the left at a distance of over a kilometer. Now, in both cases, there's still a human in the loop to make that lethal firing decision, but it's not a technological requirement. It's a choice. And it's that choice that I want to focus on, because as we migrate lethal decision-making from humans to software,
On Hacker News
There's likely a slippery slope fallacy in there somewhere (I hope). If interested in the (not so) sci-fi aspects of automated weapons and their ramifications, I often plug Daniel Suarez's great Kill Decision talk and book: [VIDEO] — jameslk, 2025-08
When you see governments already contemplating killing people based on algorithms, you begin to empathize with Musk about calling AI a "demon" that we're summoning: [LINK] However right now I'm much more afraid of governments "setting loose" autonomous killer robots than I am about Skynet-like self-conscious killer robots (which may be what Musk is thinking about). To the people being on the rece… — higherpurpose, 2014-10
This is only going to get worse if they make drones autonomous, which this TED talk shows they have a lot of reasons for why they will want to make them autonomous, unless there's huge public outcry demanding a ban: [VIDEO] — salient, 2013-12
Jacob Appelbaum has been saying this for a while already. They use NSA's data to do "signature strikes", i.e. strikes where they may assassinate someone only based on the "harmless metadata" they have on him. Talked to someone who may have talked to someone else from a "terrorist organization"? Well, you may now be on a drone target list. This is going to get exponentially worse as they move to a… — higherpurpose, 2014-02
What might happen is what I heard recently being called the "morality apocalypse" [1], i.e. technology is improving so fast, but we're not going to use it properly, probably not unlike when US used the atomic bomb on Japan the first time. It was a time when discovering the atomic bomb surpassed our morality by a long shot, and it took quite a few decades for our morality to catch-up to the techno… — higherpurpose, 2014-01
Related videos
- Enterprise Sales | Startup School · Y Combinator · 23:07
- The Cardboard Box Reform - Nixon's Ghost Bill & A Crucial Flaw in Democracy · CRI · 1:02:37
- NSA operation ORCHESTRA: Annual Status Report · HUP · 46:06
- What Happened to Horses Is Happening to Us · CGP Grey · 15:00
- Mechanical Computer (All Parts) - Basic Mechanisms In Fire Control Computers · Excelsior10000 · 41:53
- U.S. NAVY BASIC MECHANISMS OF FIRE CONTROL COMPUTERS MECHANICAL COMPUTER INSTRUCTIONAL FILM 27794 · PeriscopeFilm · 19:42
- The Secret War · Sergio IQ · 4:55:45
- This Is What Winning Looks Like (Full Length) · VICE · 1:29:10
- Tiedustelueverstin arvio Venäjästä | 3.12.2018 · fin_topsu · 1:00:22
- Why Would AI Want to do Bad Things? Instrumental Convergence · Robert Miles AI Safety · 10:35
- Veritasium: What Everyone Gets Wrong About AI and Learning – Derek Muller Explains · Perimeter Institute for Theoretical Physics · 1:15:10
- Secret History of Silicon Valley · Computer History Museum · 1:02:47
- David Fravor: UFOs, Aliens, Fighter Jets, and Aerospace Engineering | Lex Fridman Podcast #122 · Lex Fridman · 3:56:24
- Intelligence and Stupidity: The Orthogonality Thesis · Robert Miles AI Safety · 13:02
- The Battle of Midway 1942: Told from the Japanese Perspective (1/3) · Montemayor · 41:46
- We're building a dystopia just to make people click on ads | Zeynep Tufekci · TED · 22:55