VCF East: Xerox Star vs. Apple Lisa

Channel:Vintage Computer Federation · Length:42:38 · Published:2020-12-30 · Views:40970

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Jason Perkins's talk at Vintage Computer Festival East 2020 compares the user interface of the Xerox Star with that of the Apple Lisa. It covers editing documents, the Star's mouse and a Q&A.

Why HN recommends it

Shared as a recent, detailed comparison of the two early GUIs and where their conventions differ.

this video comparing the Apple Lisa to the Xerox Star highlights the differences — HN, 2025

History of computing · GUI, HCI & interface history · Demoscene & retrocomputing

Subtitles (excerpt)

Hi, I'm Jason Perkins and today I'm going to be giving a demo of VCS Xerox 8010 Star. Uh first of all, I wanted to show the actual size of this thing. So, this is the main cabinet of the Star 8010 workstation. For reference, this is a 3 and 1/2 in disk. This is an 8 in disk and then, you know, regular Sharpie. So, it's It is not a a small system. The front of the machine there is a a maintenance panel with uh some seven-segment displays that give a the current status of the machine, a reset, alternate boot, and your power switch. It has a Shugart 8 in floppy drive. Which holds 600 kilobytes. I'm just going to wheel this back under here so that it's out of the way. All right. The graphical interface that the Star uses is called Viewpoint and is arguably the first commercial graphical user interface. Certainly, there were ones that existed before this. This was really the first one meant for public consumption. It's often been said that Apple copied Xerox and the ideas that the Star had with the Lisa and certainly a lot of people who worked on the software on this moved to Apple and developed the software for the Lisa. But, I don't think that's entirely fair to say because while certainly there are

On Hacker News

Here's video of Xerox personel demonstrating the Star 8010 UI back in the day. [LINK] Also, a more recent look at both the Star 8010 and the Apple Lisa. [VIDEO] — GeekyBear, 2023-05
Meh. the Lisa was absolutely, positively, explicitly NOT a Mac. If you don't get that, then you misunderstand the business of computing in the late 70s / early 80s. The author also ignored Jef Raskin's work on the original Mac project (I wrote a serial driver for him in the early 80s for a 6809 prototype he was working on.) If you're going to make one of these Mac hagiographies, it's useful to po… — OhMeadhbh, 2026-04
I remember trying out Plan 9 a few years ago. I like its underpinnings; I like how the designers pushed the Unix notion of "everything is a file" to its limits, with various services being presented to the operating system as file servers implemented using a protocol named 9P. It's a cool research operating system with a lot of very interesting ideas, but ultimately it's not my daily driver due t… — linguae, 2025-10

Related videos