Why Can't we Remake the Rocketdyne F1 Engine?

Channel:Curious Droid · Length:5:03 · Published:2018-07-24 · Views:4201673

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Short Curious Droid video on why NASA could not simply rebuild the Saturn V's Rocketdyne F-1 engine for the SLS boosters. It explains that the engines were hand-tailored and that much of the know-how was never documented, so the blueprints were not enough.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as the standard illustration of lost tacit knowledge and why old blueprints cannot be turned back into hardware.

TLDR: everything was handcrafted, notes were not made or lost — HN, 2021

Space exploration & spaceflight · Mechanical & precision engineering

Subtitles (excerpt)

As we advance our technology ever forward you would think that remaking a 50-year old design should be easy but things are not quite as simple as they first seem. When the Space Launch System or the SLS was in development NASA ran the advanced booster competition to find a new booster system and two of the three entries used liquid fuel engines. Liquid fuel boosters would be safer and could be shut down in the event of a problem unlike the solid rocket boosters which cant. However unlike the space shuttle the new boosters would be single-use only and would burn up when they fell back to earth but which liquid fuel engines would be powerful enough there really aren't any massive engines in use today. The boosters could use four same modified RS-25D the engines those left over from a space shuttle program which would also be used the SLS's main core stage but that will be very wasteful of a complex expensive and yet highly efficient engine. Now we've already had an engine capable of doing the job, the mighty Rocketdyne F-1 the huge engines which took men to the moon with the Apollo program but they haven't been built since the 1960s. The F-1 engines were not only extremely powerful but they were also simple which meant they

On Hacker News

Sure. Not a source but still interesting. [VIDEO] (Why Can't we Remake the Rocketdyne F1 Engine?) TLDR: everything was handcrafted, notes were not made or lost, people have retired or passed away and today's engineers don't know the tricks that the original engineers used. Effectively, existing blueprints are not enough to rebuild the engine. — lmilcin, 2021-07
Technical know how, mostly. But in expected ways. Machining and engineering skills as they relate to manufacturing are different now. [VIDEO] — CountSessine, 2022-02
Reminds me of how NASA had to design completely new rocket engines for SLS because while they still had the plans for the Saturn-V rocket engines, back then plans weren't followed to such high accuracy as nowadays a 3D model would be followed. Each engine was custom tailored with small modifications here and there. The knowledge to custom tailor them was lost, so they went with designing new engi… — est31, 2021-03
You'd have to redesign it from scratch - it would be faster. Which is what happened with the SLS engine/launch vehicle. Duplicating the F1 would involve technology and knowledge of individual engineers who are dead and corporations that no longer exist. The TACIT knowledge and technologies required to go with the blueprints died with them. [LINK] [LINK] [VIDEO] — xyzzy21, 2021-03
Yup that's what curious droid's video on this is saying as well [1]. Basically the plans all were off a little bit and each rocket engine was hand-tailored to the demands of the individual rocket by these skilled people you mentioned. They did document their changes but only on scrap notes that since were lost. The plans themselves that were archived don't contain those notes and even if they had… — est31, 2019-07

Related videos