Feynman: Mathematicians versus Physicists

Channel:TehPhysicalist · Length:9:46 · Published:2012-05-17 · Views:883652

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A ten-minute clip of Richard Feynman describing how mathematicians and physicists differ in their interests and customs. He argues physics rests on visualizing and applying math rather than pure abstraction.

Why HN recommends it

The reference people reach for when debating how math differs from physics.

Feynman's quite interesting talking about it here — HN, 2015

Pure mathematics · Fundamental physics · Scientific method & science communication

Subtitles (excerpt)

now I would like to make a number of remarks on the relation of mathematics and physics which are a little more General the first is that the mathematicians only are dealing with the structure of the reasoning and they do not really care about what they're talking they don't even need to know what they're talking about or as they themselves say or whether what they say is true now explain that if you state the axioms you say such and such a so and such and such a so and such and such a so what then then the logic can be carried out without knowing what the such and such words mean that is if they if the statements about the axim are true I mean are carefully formulated and complete enough it is not necessary for the man who's doing the reasoning to have any knowledge of the meaning of these words and to be able to deduce in the same language new con con new conclusions if I use the word triangle in one of the axioms there'd be some statement about triangles in the conclusion whereas the man who's doing the reasoning might not know what the triangle is but then I can read his thing back and say oh a triangle that's just a three side of what have you this so and so and so I know this new fact in other words mathematicians

On Hacker News

There's a lot of physics that isn't maths - more visualising how stuff works. Feynman's quite interesting talking about it here [VIDEO] — tim333, 2015-01
I had to laugh when I saw my response next to @getsat's. Both are valid viewpoints. In other words, not everyone who uses tools has to know how to make tools. Tool makers have more insight into the assumptions behind the tools they create -- they might know how a tool was meant to be used and what its limits are. That being said, there are times when using a screwdriver as a hammer is expedient a… — coldnebo, 2014-12
Feynman said the same: [VIDEO] I’ll take him and Sabine, and my 24 yo masters in elastic structures, over your entitled screed any day. — compiskey, 2022-11
> In modern physics of this type, where experimentation is not practical, the math is the physics I think Feynmann would disagree with you. [VIDEO] — monocasa, 2018-05
This gentleman needs to watch Feynman talking about the difference between maths and physics. Science is all about gathering evidence and the scientific method focuses very heavily on observation and testing . Basically, it is impossible to conduct science without data. Maths is data independent. More data or less data doesn't influence what maths is. Maths links the axiom and the result - once a… — roenxi, 2017-06

Related videos