The Tragedy of systemd
Channel:linux.conf.au · Length:47:18 · Published:2019-01-24 · Views:1284740
Summary
FreeBSD developer Benno Rice traces the history of init and bootstrap systems at linux.conf.au 2019 to explain why systemd was seen as necessary and why it provokes such strong reactions. He also discusses why change is scary.
Why HN recommends it
The most-recommended balanced take on systemd, from a BSD perspective, handed to anyone caught up in the systemd debate.
is an interesting talk on this topic from the view of someone (Benno Rice) in BSD land. Highly recommended. — HN, 2024
Operating systems & kernels · Linux & open-source ecosystems
Subtitles (excerpt)
right thanks everybody for coming and please welcome dinner rice so I know this may come as a shock to some of you but I have opinions so this is one of those talks where I started you know I had a kind of idea and I came up with the title and suddenly it all started to really come into place because you know especially when I looked up what tragedy what wikipedia said the tragedy meant which is a form of drama based on human suffering that invokes an accompanying catharsis or pleasure in audiences and I figured that was enough suffering in this whole subject to go around and you know hopefully I can deliver some pleasure on to my audience another big influence on this talk is a piece that everyone should have read by now and if they haven't please go read it it's by Oren sure it is called contempt culture the gist of that piece is that people use contempt as a social signifier it's and the piece itself is largely based around language communities so the Python community rags on the purl community and the purl community rag on the pH of he community and so on and so forth but a lot of the concepts in it are largely applicable outside of that and the last concept that really fed into this talk was change change is a tricky thing has
On Hacker News
I linked it elsewhere in this thread, but you should really watch this talk, particularly 12:45 through 16:20: [VIDEO] tl;dr: systemd isn't meant to be an init system, it's meant to manage services, and the alternative world where you don't have a unified system for managing services and events actually sucks. — nickysielicki, 2025-09
There is a wonderful talk by Benno Rice a few years ago. Insightful and entertaining. Not focussed only on the negatives, BTW. [LINK] [VIDEO] HN discusion: [LINK] LWN comments: [LINK] — fermigier, 2025-01
[VIDEO] (The Tragedy of systemd) is an interesting talk on this topic from the view of someone (Benno Rice) in BSD land. Highly recommended. EDIT: this is mentioned in the article, thanks koalacola — SahAssar, 2024-08
It’s interesting you say that? It runs completely counter to my experience coming from the “BSD-style” rc.d init Arch used to use, and migrating to systemd. Any specific issues? I didn’t see any. No offense. One factor may be that Arch prioritizes not patching upstream - helped save them from targeting here, and it doesn’t go overboard with default configs, which I’ve long appreciated. Not to dis… — TimeBearingDown, 2024-04
> Turning Linux into Windows by replicating svchost.exe shouldn't be applauded by the Linux community. ... We've got Linux's PID 1 (for most distros) controlled by a MS employee, who replicated Windows' svchost.exe. And people are all excited? systemd was pretty consciously patterned after launchd, not svchost. The goal was, and for good reasons, to make Linux behave like a more integrated Unix-l… — eropple, 2024-04
Related videos
- The Antique Microwave Oven that's Better than Yours · Technology Connections · 14:20
- "Simple Made Easy" - Rich Hickey (2011) · Strange Loop Conference · 1:01:38
- I Shot You First: Networking the Gameplay of Halo: Reach · GDC Festival of Gaming · 1:49:07
- Why Trains Suck in America · Wendover Productions · 8:25
- This Video Is Sponsored By ███ VPN · Tom Scott · 7:25
- WOKE BRANDS · hbomberguy · 26:44
- Failing to Fail: The Spiderweb Software Way · GDC Festival of Gaming · 59:47
- This is Financial Advice · Folding Ideas · 2:31:43
- Carl Sagan - Cosmos - Eratosthenes · carlsagandotcom · 6:41
- Cities Aren't Loud: Cars Are Loud · Not Just Bikes · 17:08
- The Truth About Electric Towing · Aging Wheels · 25:58
- How Python was Shaped by leaky Internals, Armin Ronacher, Flask framework · Видео с мероприятий {speach! · 49:55
- "Unison: a new distributed programming language" by Paul Chiusano · Strange Loop Conference · 41:05
- Maybe Not - Rich Hickey · ClojureTV · 1:03:28
- 2023 LLVM Dev Mtg - Mojo 🔥: A system programming language for heterogenous computing · LLVM · 49:48
- Why Electric Bikes are More Dangerous than Motorcycles · FortNine · 6:18
- Essential Ideas for Parents · Jason Salotti · 2:51:43