The Great Tragedy of the 'Buffy' HD Remaster
Channel:Passion of the Nerd · Length:19:43 · Published:2019-03-21 · Views:1391792
Summary
A critique of the HD remaster of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, walking through cropping, color and effects problems that damaged the original look. It also advises which versions to buy.
Why HN recommends it
Used as the main example of bad HD restorations and aspect-ratio recropping of older TV shows.
A great breakdown of the problems is on YouTube here — HN, 2024
Audio & video engineering · Film & TV clips · Film analysis & criticism
Subtitles (excerpt)
We truly do live in a gilded age of television. The internet era brought with it things like DVR and the streaming services which have made it possible for people to easily follow season-long story arcs. Consequently in many ways, long form storytelling on television has surpassed the scope and depth of your average theater experience. "Dracarys." But it isn’t only that. Classic television which we once had to watch through the bottom of a coke bottle is being restored to a glory the likes of which we’ve never gotten to see. With these remasters, studios are going back to the original films the shows were shot on, creating brand new high definition scans of them, and updating their special effects while keeping the original flavor. Many of these beautiful restorations have been done with a meticulous attention to detail and with loving care for the original source material. And then… And then...there is the 'Buffy' remaster… Why do ALL THEIR FACES LOOK LIKE RUBBER DOLLS? Oh come ON. That’s not even the same color! It’s DAY TIME. YOU CAN SEE THE CREW. JUST CROP THEM OUT!!! [Buffy crying] *sigh* I’m going to need a lot of wine for this one. Before we get into this, if you’re unfamiliar with the show
On Hacker News
Also the Buffy remaster, where interestingly they uncropped the footage, showing some of the filming crew, microphones, etc. [VIDEO] (edit: already posted in this thread, oops: [LINK] ) — remram, 2021-10
Not every HD redo is better. [VIDEO] And honestly a ton of why dvds look so terrible is people forgot about deinterlacing. Toggle it on and things look a lot better. — upon_drumhead, 2024-07
The automated HD 'remaster' of Buffy is the prime example of how badly this can go wrong. A great breakdown of the problems is on YouTube here: [VIDEO] — echelon_musk, 2024-04
Agree. All those remastering are often done with more importance given to the economic side of things, instead of respecting the art. Some are destroying the original work. The first thing that pop into my mind is how they destroyed Buffy with the HD makeover: [VIDEO] As a reddit commenter said about the cropping job: "All they had to do was nothing and they still fucked it up." It's a disgrace. — BiteCode_dev, 2023-12
There are way more issues with Buffy on top of that too, and my Disney ire will forever be stoked until they rectify the situation (as the current owners of 20th Century Television.) [LINK] [VIDEO] — Andrex, 2021-10
Related videos
- D/A and A/D | Digital Show and Tell (Monty Montgomery @ xiph.org) · FL Studio · 23:52
- Jackie Chan - How to Do Action Comedy · Every Frame a Painting · 9:04
- Everything is a Remix (Original Series) · Kirby Ferguson · 37:30
- The world's worst video card? · Ben Eater · 32:47
- The Marvel Symphonic Universe · Every Frame a Painting · 13:35
- Threads (1984) ORIGINAL TRAILER [HD 1080p] · HD Retro Trailers · 2:23
- Floyd Toole - Sound reproduction – art and science/opinions and facts · CIRMMT · 1:13:56
- Margin Call (2011) - Senior Partners Emergency Meeting [HD 1080p] (Re-Upload / Audio Fixed) · Extractor · 9:48
- The Spectacular Failure of the Star Wars Hotel · Jenny Nicholson · 4:05:39
- Akira Kurosawa - Composing Movement · Every Frame a Painting · 8:24
- MiniDisc - An Appreciation · Techmoan · 44:39
- Cassettes - better than you don't remember · Techmoan · 22:46
- Why is TV 29.97 frames per second? · Stand-up Maths · 14:27
- Margin Call (9/9) Movie CLIP - It's Just Money (2011) HD · Movieclips · 3:42
- E-paper hacking: fastest possible refresh rate · Applied Science · 27:55
- Vancouver Never Plays Itself · Every Frame a Painting · 9:06