Windows "SUCKS": How I'd Fix it by a retired Microsoft Windows engineer

Channel:Dave's Garage · Length:16:09 · Published:2025-11-06 · Views:583285

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Dave Plummer, a retired Microsoft engineer who wrote Task Manager, responds to the claim that Windows sucks. He describes how he would fix common annoyances, in what he calls a love letter to Windows wrapped in a rant.

Why HN recommends it

HN people share it in Windows 11 backlash threads as an even-handed insider's view of what is wrong with Windows.

I find this take (from the guy who wrote the Windows task manager while at Microsoft) to be evenhanded. — HN, 2026

Operating systems & kernels · Tech company stories & documentaries · UX & UI design

Subtitles (excerpt)

Windows sucks. There, I said it right at the top so the algorithm can put this episode in the same playlist as rants about dishwasher soap pods and the world's most disappointing sports car. But if you stick with me past the cold open, I'm going to do something that won't actually get me invited to many brand loyalty barbecues. I'm going to argue that windows really does suck for some people and some of the time and for reasons that are pretty specific once you peel back the paint. because I helped paint a few coats of those myself back in the 90s. I'm going to show you where the brush strokes went wrong, who they were meant for, and how I would fix it if, heaven help us, I were suddenly put in charge. Now, I worked on Windows and most of my code is likely still in there. So, of course, I'm personally invested. I'm also of the firm belief that the Windows kernel is every bit as powerful and robust as the Linux kernel. But the software, which is then layered on top of the kernel, the pieces that you and I interact with daily, have very different priorities. and what that means to users like you and me. I also want to be crystal clear about one thing upfront. I left Microsoft more than 20 years ago.

On Hacker News

I find this take (from the guy who wrote the Windows task manager while at Microsoft) to be evenhanded. > Windows "SUCKS": How I'd Fix it by a retired Microsoft Windows engineer. [VIDEO] — GeekyBear, 2026-06
The average home user probably won't know what power shell and GitHub are. I can't run the scripts you are talking about on my work pc. I can sympathise with your point of view but it does feel a bit like "works for me because I know what I'm doing". Also how long before another Windows update that undoes what the scripts do. I used to be very pro windows simply because of backwards compatibility… — pipes, 2025-12
That's an entertaining read. I binned Windows 11 recently (only kept it around for gaming) because I didn't like the direction it was clearly going (and has been for a while - including their shoehorning of AI into everything when I don't want it or need it) and don't game enough that I care much any more. For the first time since the 80's I'm not running a Windows OS on any of my machines. I dou… — noir_lord, 2025-11
Dave Plummer, retired Microsoft engineer from the early days, made a video on this 2 weeks ago: > Windows "SUCKS": How I'd Fix it by a retired Microsoft Windows engineer [VIDEO] — accrual, 2025-11

Related videos