Feynman :: Rules of Chess

Channel:defjam99b · Length:2:49 · Published:2007-02-21 · Views:1410533

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A three-minute clip of Richard Feynman using the rules of chess as an analogy for how science works, discovering rules by observation and sometimes meeting surprises like castling. It touches on incremental progress versus revolutions.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in discussions of the scientific method and empiricism as Feynman's classic analogy of watching a game to infer its rules.

Richard Feynman gave a good explanation of the principle — HN, 2021

Chess, board games & puzzles · Scientific method & science communication

On Hacker News

>It's nonsense, top-to-bottom. This isn't a formal physical theory, just a heuristic for evaluating lines of investigation. Richard Feynman gave a good explanation of the principle, which he said he found helpful in his work. [VIDEO] — simonh, 2021-01
> that we cannot use empiricism to determine universal rules, we indeed cannot do this and Feynman illustrated this frequently using the analogy of chess ( [VIDEO] ). As Kant argues we can never observe the rules of the physical world as things in themselves, just as we can't directly look at the rules of chess by observing games. We can only get individual hints that we piece together into model… — Barrin92, 2023-11
I suspect the metaphor is inspired by Feynman's one about gods playing chess [1]. As it's almost always the case, Feynman manages to immediately inspire and illuminate. On the other hand, the present article seems to me to get some important things wrong. For one, it's not the case that overall white and black win 50% of the time each. More importantly though, if somebody is interested in investi… — leto_ii, 2021-01
Science is a blackbox. We make theories about the world we live in based upon the results of experiments. Richard Feynman commented method of thinking about science on one of his videos. [VIDEO] — sevenproxies, 2011-06

Related videos