I'm Allowed to Rob You!

Channel:Larken Rose · Length:9:59 · Published:2009-11-25 · Views:237299

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short anarchist-leaning video by Larken Rose arguing that the Constitution and similar documents cannot legitimately grant anyone the right to take other people's property. It uses a rhetorical 'paper that lets me rob you' setup to challenge belief in political authority.

Why HN recommends it

Libertarian-minded commenters post it in surveillance, government and constitution threads as a red-pill argument that political authority is illusory.

Here's all you need to know about the Constitution — HN, 2015

Politics & history (other) · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

Warning, this video contains ideas which are not government approved. Hello, my name is Lurin Rose and uh like a lot of people these days, I'm fairly strapped for cash, but I think I've come up with a solution. I'm allowed to rob you. Having to earn money is just too inconvenient. So, I just gave myself permission to rob you. So, I'll be by your house around, let's say, noon tomorrow to uh see which of your stuff I want to take. Now, this isn't just a threat. I'm not just saying I'm going to rob you. I by writing this down gave myself the moral right to rob you. So, maybe maybe I should have done it like this. I hereby grant to myself the absolute moral right to steal your stuff. So, since I just gave myself the moral right to take your stuff, um I'm sure when I show up you'll give me a warm welcome. And uh in case you think I can't give to myself the right to rob you, uh some friends of mine helped me out with this one. They they signed this one. So, it isn't just me now. A lot of people have given me the right to rob you. Uh, and in case you weren't impressed with these sort of simple printouts, uh, my friends and I had a a very formal meeting and and put together this somewhat verbose

On Hacker News

> I do not understand. I thought that in the current climate, where people are becoming increasingly aware and concerned about privacy, that such laws would be expanded in scope. It's very simple. The government is not working towards our interests, but their own. That applies to every government everywhere, all throughout history, because all governments are populated by psychopaths. They don't … — kakapupu, 2017-03
In reality, it's not that complicated. Here's all you need to know about the Constitution: [VIDEO] — HiYaBarbie, 2015-09
Yeah, speaking the truth tends to get you downvoted. People are silly and emotional. But it's nice to see another independent thinker here. I've noticed you before. Don't pay much attention to the political circus though, the false choice between "Demopublicans". That's all smoke and mirrors to make you think you have a say in how you're "governed" (i.e. coerced ). > The current mess of the US ec… — sillygeese, 2015-08
The only way to "solve" the problem is to spread awareness of it. Political authority is the idea that a small group of people "has the right" to impose their will on everyone else. In reality though, they obviously do not. Everyone has the exact same rights (and they don't include coercing other people), and you can't delegate rights you do not have. But the belief in political authority is the … — anoncowherd, 2013-12
I can't tell what you're trying to convey. You may just be trolling, of course. "The rule of law" sounds good and all, but you have to differentiate between laws that are only detrimental to us, and laws that would actually correspond to morals: 1) Don't aggress against others, 2) Don't violate others' property rights.. and those are the only two laws you need. Now we've got like hundreds of thou… — HiYaBarbie, 2015-09

Related videos