Why Teleportation Would Kill You

Channel:CGP Grey · Length:5:44 · Published:2016-03-07 · Views:7300520

Watch on YouTube

Summary

CGP Grey asks whether Star Trek-style teleportation would kill you and recreate a copy, working through the philosophy of identity and the Ship of Theseus. It is a short animated explainer.

Why HN recommends it

Pointed to in threads about mind uploading and teleportation as a good, accessible look at personal identity.

CGP Grey has a good look at the question wrt Star Trek teleportation — HN, 2018

Consciousness & cognition · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

In Star Trek, the transporter moves you from one spot to another, saving on shuttle fuel (and special effects budgets). In-universe, it's 'the safest way to travel'. Yes, *sometimes*, two guys die horrible, mutilated deaths under rare circumstances... ...but trillions of individuals transport to work every morning without a hiccup. But, what if the transporter isn't as safe as claimed... ...what if the death rate isn't point almost nothing percent, but one-hundred percent... ...because the transporter is a suicide box. First, how does the transporter work? There are technical manuals, with pages and pages of hilariously over-specific details... that yet say *so little*. Star Trek is nothing if not consistently inconsistent, but, taking the most common elements: First, the transporter scans you down to the quark, takes apart your atoms and sends the pieces of you to the destination for reassembly. But, is it *you* on the other end? Or a copy that thinks it's you? Well, who *is* you? That's a hell of a big question, but let's try to be good scientists about it: ...we don't assume there's a magic part of you that can't be measured. After all, if it can't be measured, that means by definition it can't affect anything.

On Hacker News

This question descends from an ancient philosophical question; see the Ship of Theseus[0]. CGP Grey has a good look at the question wrt Star Trek teleportation[1]. [0] [LINK] [1] [VIDEO] — macintux, 2018-03
That’s a great question that’s been pondered by philosophers for a while: [LINK] Here’s a fun video talking about the same thing: [VIDEO] — rendezvouscp, 2016-03
> a YouTube video CGP Grey: The Trouble with Transporters [VIDEO] Steve Shives: Is Star Trek's Transporter Actually a Murder Machine? [LINK] > why wouldn’t they just [LINK] For purpose of storytelling, these powerful side effects of transporters need to be restricted. Hence, as an in-universe explanation, a pattern buffer ∙ is a physical phenomenon that cannot be (fully) expressed as information … — bmn__, 2020-04
Even if we are just mass and particles, then what happens if you just skip the vaporizing part. ( [VIDEO] ) — martin-adams, 2019-04
This runs into the question of whether you're a single person. [VIDEO] [LINK] If you transplant half your brain into another body, and both of you wake up, which one is you? If you start swapping your atoms one by one with someone else, and neither of you die, at what point do you become the other person? Unfortunately questions like that are necessary in order to address the idea of a simulation… — sillysaurus3, 2017-03

Related videos