Carbon Capture Isn't Real

Channel:Adam Something · Length:3:50 · Published:2022-11-01 · Views:988248

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Adam Something gives a short, sarcastic argument that carbon capture does not live up to its promises. He says the energy it uses would be better spent replacing fossil sources directly.

Why HN recommends it

HN commenters cite it to argue carbon capture is a distraction from stopping emissions at the source.

100 times out of 100, you would rather just stop the emissions at the source by making the emitter use the green energy. — HN, 2024

Climate policy, solutions & debate

Subtitles (excerpt)

Carbon capture isn't real. Wait, yes it is! Here in Switzerland, a giant new machine is sucking carbon directly from the air. Developers say the plant will capture about 900 tons of CO2 annually, or the approximate level released from 200 cars. Or how about the world's largest carbon capture plant, Orca in Iceland, designed to filter up to 4 000 tons of CO2 a year? Yes these projects do exist and they do suck CO2 out of the atmosphere, but carbon capture as advertised still isn't real. Let me explain. So the Orca each year captures 4 000 tons of CO2, translating to about 11 tons per day, or about half a ton per hour. Capturing one ton of CO2 costs 2 650 kilowatt hours, or so they say. So here's the problem: the average coal power plant spews out about a kilogram of CO2 per kilowatt hour, meaning to produce those 2650 kilowatt hours necessary to capture one ton of CO2, the average coal power plant has to emit 2.65 tons of CO2. So if you run this carbon capture plant off a coal power plant, you'll capture one ton, and produce 2.65 tons. If your fossil power plant is the cleanest type, i.e. natural gas, and is brand new and efficient, you'll produce about 1.06 tons, practically breaking even. Hang

On Hacker News

At this point, my smell test is "how much does the 'solution' smell of gas money." and if it does, I assume they don't want to do the hard work required cause it's not in their interests, and it hasn't been for decades. ( ahem Carbon offsets) In practice it's so much harder to debunk these solutions because we don't have good ways of dealing with bad-faith actors. The non-dismissive way to view C… — xracy, 2024-08
From a logical standpoint carbon capture is a scam [0]. The argument is "if you don't have spare energy, why are you spending it on carbon capture? And if you have spare energy (you don't), why not spend the money you usee to build the over capacity to bring clean energy somewhere else?" That is all assuming your entire power grid is 100% clean (it isn't) because otherwise you fall in case 0 wher… — themoonisachees, 2022-12
Carbon capture isn't real (as advertised). If you take green energy out of the supply to capture carbon, a carbon producing power plant will have to make up for it. [1] [VIDEO] — Lariscus, 2022-11

Related videos