[AUDIO FIXED] The Truth Cannot be Sexist - Steven Pinker on the biology of sex differences

Channel:Gravitahn · Length:39:05 · Published:2017-01-02 · Views:271883

Watch on YouTube

Summary

An excerpt of the 2005 Harvard debate in which Steven Pinker gives his prepared case on biological sex differences and the under-representation of women in science. It covers cross-cultural patterns in preferences and abilities and the overlap between male and female distributions.

Why HN recommends it

Pointed to repeatedly in gender-in-tech threads, especially around the Google memo, as a science-based treatment of sex differences.

I found it to be an excellent pre-existing discussion of the merits of the memo. — HN, 2017

Social issues & culture · Psychology & human behavior · Evolution & genetics

Subtitles (excerpt)

uh it's a privilege to be uh engaged in a conversation with my uh colleague Elizabeth spelly we go back a long way uh we've been colleagues both at uh MIT where I helped attract her and at Harvard where she helped me uh like uh most people in my field I have enormous admiration for Liz's brilliant contributions to our understanding of the origins of cognition uh but we do find ourselves uh with somewhat different perspectives on a uh recent issue and for those of you who just arrived from Mars there's been a certain amount of discussion uh here at Harvard on a particular data and that is the underrepresentation of women among tenure track faculty in Elite universities in physical science math and engineering and here are some uh recent figures now uh as with many issues in Psychology there are three broad classes of explanations uh one can imagine an extreme nature position that males but not females have the talents and temperaments necessary for science needless to say uh only a Madman could believe that and uh there aren't any proponents of that position there's an extreme nurture position that males and females are bi biologically indistinguishable and all the relevant sex differences

On Hacker News

Whenever this comes up, I like to mention this video [0]. The video speaks for itself, but generally it advances the position that human behavior and preferences are a distribution, and the distributions for women are in some cases different from the distributions for men (in the sense that summary statistics like mean and variance differ), but there is always significant overlap. The position th… — ac2018-02-14, 2018-02
> The "scientific consensus" is that women are inherently genetically hard-coded to not be as good at or interested in computer programming? I did not say that, did I? The scientific consensus is that there are biological differences that have an influence on job fit and job choices. But we are talking statistics here, there are always people from the other sex that are a good fit for a specific … — onli, 2017-08
If you want to see to which points science does have something to say, you might be interested in watching [VIDEO] . This presentation by Steven Pinker got posted yesterday in one of the other comment threads, and I found it to be an excellent pre-existing discussion of the merits of the memo. — onli, 2017-08
In short, yes. You should look up the book which is cited in this video, and you should listen to the discussion of the prologue: [VIDEO] Since the human brain and its interaction with culture is very complicated, more research is needed. But a fair reading of what we have so far would seem to indicate: it's both. Beware of ideological just-so stories that make you feel good. Also, if it sounds m… — stcredzero, 2018-01
If you're looking for a more scientifically inclined video about this topic, take a look here: [VIDEO] (The Truth Cannot be Sexist - Steven Pinker on the biology of sex differences) — DidISayTooMuch, 2017-08

Related videos