Tested: Where Does The Tone Come From In An Electric Guitar?
Channel:Jim Lill · Length:11:53 · Published:2022-01-24 · Views:2932460
Summary
Guitarist Jim Lill methodically tests what in an electric guitar affects its tone, swapping parts on a partscaster and even trying a 2x4 body. He finds that wood and construction matter far less than people assume.
Why HN recommends it
Cited as a fun, experimental debunking of tonewood claims that shows electronics dominate electric guitar sound.
I recently came across an excellent video where a guitarist tries to determine exactly which parts of an electric guitar affect its tone. — HN, 2022
Music theory, synthesis & production · Scientific method & science communication
Subtitles (excerpt)
[Music] over the holidays I wanted to find out the truth about where the tone comes from in an electric guitar what makes one electric guitar sound different from another when they're plugged into the same amp I've read and heard all sorts of ways that every single part on the guitar can make a difference in the sound but I don't actually know if any of that's true I wanted to take the time to actually test them and capture the results with audio and video so you guys can see for yourself and decide what you think important too first thing I did was email three very high-end guitar Builders whose guitars I've personally played and enjoyed very much and I asked them the question what five factors in an electric guitar make the most difference in the Amplified sound here's how they responded I was surprised at how different their lists were from each other and with these factors in mind I needed a test guitar that I could hack up and change Parts on without feeling stress so so I bought a kit for $100 and put it [Music] together as a baseline I tested it against my Tom Anderson Telly because almost everything about the Anderson is different than the parts caster [Music] [Applause] [Music]
On Hacker News
An adjacent topic, since TFA is about acoustic guitars and this is about electric, but I recently came across an excellent video where a guitarist tries to determine exactly which parts of an electric guitar affect its tone. He did it by methodically swapping parts around on a cheap kit guitar and comparing the sound to a quality model, and he winds up finding the body shape/material appear to ha… — fenomas, 2022-04
If this is appealing to you, check out this guy who ran a much more systematic set of experiments on even more sacred and sensitive targets: Tested: Where Does The Tone Come From In An Electric Guitar? [VIDEO] Tested: Where Does The Tone Come From In A Guitar Amplifier? [LINK] — gadtfly, 2026-03
[VIDEO] If you're interested, this is pretty fascinating - he shows experimentaly that the guitar itself has little to do with tone. Other than that better made instruments could (no promises!) hold their tuning a little better, but you can cheaply buy locks or spend some money having that re-done. More than this and I have a hard explaining what a "pro" guitar could do to help an amateur. You ge… — dmbche, 2023-07
If you're interested in how simple they can get, "Tested: Where Does The Tone Come From In An Electric Guitar?" is a fun and technically-interesting video: [VIDEO] — CharlesW, 2022-05
>Different wood types will produce different tonal characteristics. True for acoustic guitars, but for electric guitars this is thoroughly debunked: [VIDEO] Previous HN discussion: [LINK] — mrob, 2024-04
Related videos
- Tested: Where Does The Tone Come From In A Guitar Amplifier? · Jim Lill · 18:34
- Apple Watch : Scientific Sleep Test · The Quantified Scientist · 18:20
- How Do Nuclear Submarines Make Oxygen?- Smarter Every Day 251 · SmarterEveryDay · 29:33
- Rich Harris - Rethinking reactivity · You Gotta Love Frontend · 36:45
- Transformers, the tech behind LLMs | Deep Learning Chapter 5 · 3Blue1Brown · 27:14
- America Was Wrong About Ethanol - Study Shows · Engineering Explained · 12:59
- Kostya Kimlat Fools Penn & Teller // Fool Us: Penn's Favorite Card Trick · Kostya Kimlat · 7:50
- The Quantum Conspiracy: What Popularizers of QM Don't Want You to Know · Google TechTalks · 1:03:43
- James Burke Connections, Ep. 1 "The Trigger Effect" · DRS_Education · 49:22
- Music Theory and White Supremacy · Adam Neely · 44:01
- Hamming, "You and Your Research" (June 6, 1995) · securitylectures · 44:02
- Why Being Delusional is a Superpower · Veritasium · 12:04
- Is Most Published Research Wrong? · Veritasium · 12:22
- Richard Feynman Fire · nebulajr · 4:43
- Music Software & Bad Interface Design: Avid’s Sibelius · Tantacrul · 21:35
- Powers of Ten™ (1977) · Eames Office · 9:01