Why Swiss Trains are the Best in Europe

Channel:Not Just Bikes · Length:16:52 · Published:2022-07-18 · Views:2312443

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Not Just Bikes explains why Swiss trains are considered among the best in Europe and the world, covering frequency, connections and what riding them is like.

Why HN recommends it

HN cites it as an example of public transit that runs like clockwork and is convenient enough to rival cars.

it's about making public transit so good — HN, 2023

Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

This video is sponsored by CuriosityStream and Nebula. Which is possibly the best bundle deal in video streaming but more about that later. I live in the Netherlands, where we have some pretty good trains. There’s a dense network that connects nearly all major towns and cities. The busiest train station, Utrecht Centraal, has over a thousand train departures per day. And there are also high-speed trains to neighbouring countries. For example, I can get to Paris in less than 3½ hours. But as good as we have it here in the Netherlands, there’s another country in Europe that does trains better. Much better in fact. Welcome to the Confoederatio Helvetica, or as I like to call it,. Switzerland Famous for mountains, holey cheese, chocolate, bendy knives, and time bracelets. And, of course, trains. Lots and lots of trains. Now I’ve been to Switzerland many times, and I’ve taken the train every time I’ve come, because of course I did: it’s the most efficient way to get around. But recently I stayed a full week in Switzerland, and took multiple trains per day to find out what makes these the best trains in Europe. One of the things that really sets the train system apart in Switzerland is just how extensive

On Hacker News

I want trains and public transportation. Have lived 18 years in cities that had good public transportation. The kind where 95% of the population uses it often, many daily. Had friends who owned cars and they still mostly used public transportation. The cars were something for weekend trips but those friends were the exception. Unfortunately to get to that level in California means adding 60-80 li… — ptftw, 2023-10
> Public transit is no good. It's easy and convenient: • [LINK] • [VIDEO] > I don’t want to walk to a station and then share the space with other people. I don’t want to lug grocery bags around. Alright, use a bicycle then. I hear ebikes are pretty good these days. Or use a micro car if you must: [LINK] . > I want to make pit stops. A bicycle is better than a car for this. > I want to go off road… — Mawr, 2023-10
I think this is the wrong way to think about it. It's not about taking away people's cars, it's about making public transit so good (and building cities/neighborhoods that you don't need a car in), that you don't want to take a car, because it's less convenient. [VIDEO] I think this quote really nails it: "A developed country is not where the poor have cars, it's where the rich use public transit… — xracy, 2023-01
You can do without schedules if they are frequent enough (as in, people don't have to check the schedule) This is one thing that seems to be severly lacking in the US, afaict. [VIDEO] — Akronymus, 2022-09
> Good luck in Poland, where an hour delay for a train is not a surprise. Worth remembering this is not inherent to trains, as evidenced by countries who run their trains like clockwork, e.g., the Swiss: * [VIDEO] Also the Japanese, who issue official apologies when trains leave 20-25 seconds earlier : * [LINK] * [LINK] (Presumably because people time their connections so closely.) — throw0101a, 2022-08

Related videos