The Speed of Light is NOT About Light
Channel:PBS Space Time · Length:12:46 · Published:2015-10-07 · Views:7136517
Summary
PBS Space Time argues that the speed of light is better understood as the speed of causality, the universal limit on how fast cause and effect propagate. Light travels at that speed because it is massless, but the limit itself is a property of spacetime.
Why HN recommends it
HN commenters send people to it whenever a thread confuses the speed of light with a light-specific limit, and several say it deepened their understanding of relativity.
The video about “the speed of causality” is the one that caused me to level up — HN, 2020
Subtitles (excerpt)
♪ (PBS Digital Studios theme) ♪ Does the speed of light actually have anything to do with light? ♪ (Space Time theme) ♪ So what is it about the speed of light that's so special? Why does the universe seem to conspire to, 1) keep photons from traveling at any speed but 300,000 kilometers per second in a vacuum, according to any observer, and, 2) keep anything from traveling faster than that speed? The answer: this statement is false, or at least backwards. The universe doesn't arrange itself to keep the speed of light constant. In fact, spacetime couldn't care less about light. The cosmic speed limit is about something much deeper. This universal constant is, perhaps more accurately, the 'speed of causality'. In a previous episode, we talked about causality by way of the 'spacetime interval'. Causal connections give us the only ordering of events that all observers will agree on. But why must causality have a maximum speed? And why is that speed the same as the speed of light? To understand this, let's first get our heads around two of the most important insights in physics ever. Ready? First, 1632—frilly collars, pilgrims in Plymouth, and in Italy, Galileo was about to be dragged off
On Hacker News
There's an episode of PBS Space Time about this, "The Speed of Light is NOT About Light" [1], which comes pretty close to making the same points you are making. It might be useful to watch this earlier episode, "Are Space and Time an Illusion?" [2], first. There is a later episode (or maybe a couple of them) that go into how interactions with the Higgs field make it so things with mass travel slo… — tzs, 2020-11
PBS SpaceTime has a treatise on relativity. There are a dozen videos worth watching on this topic alone. The video about “the speed of causality” is the one that caused me to level up: [VIDEO] Here is a 12 video playlist on relativity: [LINK] Here is a six video series on measuring space and time: [LINK] — willis936, 2020-10
As an aside, the PBS space time video The Speed of Light is NOT About Light : [VIDEO] As an aside to the aside - as I rewatch it I quickly notice how young he looks (and then note the date is 2015 on there - one of the early ones and the production is less refined). You may also like The Geometry of Causality [LINK] — shagie, 2022-08
You’re correct. The speed of light is not actually about light. [VIDEO] has a great explanation from the always excellent PBS Space Time, for the curious. — cthalupa, 2020-10
Some of the confusion is, I think from referring to speed of light as "speed of light". When it really is speed limit of causality between 2 points in space. And light (em waves) just happen to be able to hit that limit. Now since expansion of space is itself not going to allow one point in space to cause any effect on another, it (the expansion) can be faster than speed of causality. PBS space t… — rhinokungfu, 2019-12
Related videos
- I tried using AI. It scared me. · Tom Scott · 15:49
- Quantum Entanglement and the Great Bohr-Einstein Debate | Space Time | PBS Digital Studios · PBS Space Time · 14:02
- The Geometry of Causality · PBS Space Time · 16:07
- Are Space and Time An Illusion? · PBS Space Time · 8:54
- Monktoberfest 2016: Bryan Cantrill - Oral Tradition in Software Engineering · RedMonk Tech Events · 47:59
- Neil deGrasse Tyson - We Stopped Dreaming (Episode 1) · Evan Schurr · 5:19
- Can YOU Fix Climate Change? · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 15:49
- Ron Vale (UCSF, HHMI) 1: Molecular Motor Proteins · Science Communication Lab · 35:25
- Investigation: How Roblox Is Exploiting Young Game Developers · People Make Games · 22:44
- The lamps you're not allowed to have. Exploring the Dubai lamps · bigclivedotcom · 32:17
- We WILL Fix Climate Change! · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 14:11
- A Selfish Argument for Making the World a Better Place – Egoistic Altruism · Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell · 7:15
- How We Bought Our Abandoned House in Japan | Process, Costs, Risks, Finance, How to Find One · Tokyo Llama · 31:44
- How to write cuneiform with Irving Finkel and @preservethings I Curator's Corner S4 Ep9 · The British Museum · 26:16
- Math's Fundamental Flaw · Veritasium · 33:59
- The Brexit effect: how leaving the EU hit the UK | FT Film · Financial Times · 28:24
- "Pipe Dream" - Animusic.com · AnimusicLLC · 3:28
- Why Heat Pumps are Immensely Important Right Now · Technology Connections · 21:03
- VFX Artists React to DUNE Bad & Great CGi · Corridor Crew · 21:40
- Roblox Pressured Us to Delete Our Video. So We Dug Deeper. · People Make Games · 35:21