Harlan Ellison -- Pay the Writer

Channel:Nicholas Horton · Length:3:25 · Published:2007-11-07 · Views:1346366

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A three-minute rant by Harlan Ellison, excerpted from the documentary Dreams with Sharp Teeth, on why creative professionals should always be paid for their work rather than work for free or 'exposure'.

Why HN recommends it

The standard link whenever someone asks creatives to work unpaid or for publicity.

The creative business is always trying to get something for nothing. — HN, 2020

Labor, work & inequality · Literature & writing craft

Subtitles (excerpt)

Get a call yesterday from a little film company down here in the valley and they're doing the packaging for um uh for MGM on uh not MGM for Warner Brothers on Babylon 5 which I worked on and I did a very long very interesting uh on camera interview about the making of Babylon 5 early on when Joe Straczynski hired me and they want to use it. A young woman calls me and she says uh we'd like to use it on the DVD. Uh can that be arranged? And I said absolutely all you got to do is pay me and she said what? I said you got to pay me. She said well everybody else is just you know doing it for nothing. I said everybody else may be an [ __ ] but I'm not. I said by what right would you call me and ask me to work for nothing? Do you get a paycheck? Well yes. I said does your boss get a paycheck? Do you tell do you pay the telecine guy? Do you pay the cameraman? Do you pay the cutters? Do you pay the the the the the teamsters when they schlepped the your stuff on the trucks? Then how don't you pay us how would you go to a gas station and ask me to give you free gas? Would you go to the doctor and have him take out your spleen for nothing? How dare you call me and want me to work for nothing? Well it would be good publicity.

On Hacker News

Harlan Ellison has a good take on it from a writer's perspective. The creative business is always trying to get something for nothing. [VIDEO] — athms, 2020-10
This is less about "can" and more about "should". It's bad for everybody when professionals work "for publicity" or are encouraged to do so, despite the relative innocence of the professional who chooses to do so. For the least subtle take on this possible, see: [VIDEO] — happytoexplain, 2021-05
Even if you're established in your career ... they'll ask you. As Harlan Ellison demonstrates: [VIDEO] — duxup, 2021-05
> Is art, similarly to science, not an iterative process based on the input of dozens, hundreds, thousands of people that came before us? Are we all not standing on the shoulders of giants, pushing just a few steps forward more, both because we like what came before us but want to see it go someplace new? Yes, and a lot of us want to be paid for our contributions to this mass endeavour. Case in p… — coldtea, 2014-06
this video interview with harlan ellison seems relevant here (warning, language): [VIDEO] perhaps profit sharingbased on unique views might be a solution to the problem. — joshAg, 2013-03

Related videos