The Surprising History of Copyright and What It Means For...

Channel:Google TechTalks · Length:54:57 · Published:2007-10-09 · Views:19420

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Karl Fogel's 2006 Google Tech Talk traces copyright from a 16th-century English censorship law to a distribution monopoly. It then surveys alternative economic bases for creation and distribution.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it as the go-to history of copyright, arguing it was a gatekeeping tool and that creators don't need it.

Karl Fogel does a great job explaining the History of copyright — HN, 2016

Hacker culture & free software · Law, policing & justice · World history

Subtitles (excerpt)

>> FOGEL: This is pretty much a slideless talk. Really, the only slides you need is the one right behind me. Everything that I refer to is linked to from this site QuestionCopyright.org. I'm very glad to see all of you here, thanks a lot for coming. It's nice to see that many people are interested in copyright, its history and its effects. Before I begin the talk proper, I want to tell you about a talk by the Google Policy Team at 3:30 over in Tech Talk 42 [INDISTINCT]. They have come in from Washington D.C. and they're going to tell us what they're doing there, net neutrality, child protection and other stuff. I guarantee you. These two talks will not overlap because I'm going to that talk. So you don't have to worry you can go to it too. And speaking of Google Policy, I want to start out with a disclaimer. The content of my talk is not in any way the official position of Google on copyright or intellectual property or anything else. It has not been endorsed by the Google Policy Team, not by the Google Legal Team. I'm very glad that Google is the sort of Organization that holds open forums like this but they should not be held responsible for its content. And with that, let's begin.

On Hacker News

>>but that's all it is, a justification. And in my opinion, that justification results in less original content. Given that more content from more people is being created today that at any point in human history runs counter to your statement Copyright is about protecting the Gatekeepers, the Movies Studios, the Music Labels, the Book Publisher, not about protecting creators. Karl Fogel does a gr… — syshum, 2016-11
Why would any fan of someones work buy a knock-off copy? We can safely assume they are a fan, otherwise why would even buy it? Also, painting is a physical object. It's a one of a kind. EDIT: your objection and many many other questions like that are nicely argued against here: [VIDEO] (The Surprising History of Copyright talk by Karl Fogel) — exo762, 2021-08
>>Copyright limitations are a reasonable thing for society to extend to content producers. No they really are not, and have never been Copyright, historically, is a tool for Information Gatekeeping, censorship, and profiteering. Not one of benfiting the Creators of content See the Talk on the History of Copyright [VIDEO] We see this every day in the modern era where copyright is used to censor cr… — syshum, 2017-04
>>It only creates a monopoly for other's books. That is far from "all it does", YouTube is a prime example of the suppression forces inherent in copy right law, and the amount of abuse that occurs chilling speech and public participation >>You really should consider the other part of the equation. Authors need to eat. No I really should not. That is not the goal nor desire of copyright law. profi… — syshum, 2020-07
>> The purpose of copyright is to provide an incentive to produce creative works False, the purpose, and only reason for copy right is to promote the useful sciences, all other reasons are UnConstitutional (from a US Stand point anyway) The Surprising History of Copyright: [VIDEO] [LINK] — the_ancient, 2016-02

Related videos