Two Monkeys Were Paid Unequally: Excerpt from Frans de Waal's TED Talk

Channel:TED Blog Video · Length:2:44 · Published:2013-04-04 · Views:25464157

Watch on YouTube

Summary

A short excerpt from Frans de Waal's TED talk showing a capuchin monkey fairness experiment in which two monkeys are paid unequally, one with cucumber and one with grapes. The shortchanged monkey reacts angrily.

Why HN recommends it

HN uses it again and again as shorthand for the idea that resentment of unfair pay and inequality is built into primates, including us.

This is the video that explains the best — HN, 2019

Psychology & human behavior · Animals & nature · Philosophy & ethics

Subtitles (excerpt)

so final experiment that I want to mention to you is our fairness study uh and so this this became a very famous study and there's now many more because after we did this about 10 years ago uh it became very well known and we did that originally with kuchin monkeys and I'm going to show you the first experiment that we did it has now been done with dogs and with birds and with chimpanzees um but we s BR and we started out with kuch and WKYS so what we did is we put two capuchin monkeys side by side again these animals they live in a group they know each other we take them out of the group put them in a test chamber and there's a very simple task that they need to do and if you give both of them cucumber for the task the two monkeys side by side they're perfectly willing to do this 25 times in a row so cucumber even though it's really only water in my opinion but cucumber is perfectly fine for them now if you give the partner grapes the food preferences of my capucha monkeys correspond exactly with the prices in the supermarket and so if you give them grapes that's a far better food uh then you create inequity between them so that's the experiment we did recently we videotaped it with new monkeys who had never done the task thinking

On Hacker News

This is the video that explains the best how the "morality" is natural even in the capuchin monkeys: [VIDEO] So, no to those that claim that, humans aren't special, and no, the good sides of morality don't come from religion, especially not from the modern ones with a "jealous" god (killing homosexuals, or punishing women when not wearsing something, however, if that is considered "morality", ind… — acqq, 2019-04
There's a nice video from a psychological experiment that illustrates it: [VIDEO] I think evolution hardwired our primate brains against inequality. We go out of our way to punish those who don't play nice and share with the broader group. Otherwise complex societies would have never emerged, because assholes exploiting and taking advantage of peers would ruin and doom any group larger than a few… — Qem, 2024-05
This experiment, listed in one table and in the references but not discussed elsewhere, would suggest otherwise: [VIDEO] There might be other confounding factors in that experiment, but for the life of me I can't imagine what they would be. My stats knowledge has evaporated over the years so I can't follow exactly what the study is doing to come to their conclusion, but it strains my credulity to… — frereubu, 2024-12
I think you're right, but historically there have been problems. Frans de Waal has written about how in his field there was a lot of early egregious anthropomorphizing. As people realized how flawed that was, they swung around the other way, to refusing to consider analogous human behavior. But things like de Waal's work demonstrating moral sense in animals is hard to explain in any other way. [1… — wpietri, 2024-05
This is how we're wired as a species, and frankly more than just a species. We don't just look at what we have and what we want, we look at what other people have and ask ourselves why they got it and we didn't. At a basic level it's an instinct that exists in lower primates, and in us as well. [VIDEO] The difference with us is that we can learn and understand the reasons why one person gets a "g… — EA-3167, 2023-08

Related videos