Why Trains Suck in America

Channel:Wendover Productions · Length:8:25 · Published:2016-08-16 · Views:5963937

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Wendover Productions explains why US passenger rail lags behind other countries. It covers freight companies owning most of the track, geography and population density, and the economics of competing with flying.

Why HN recommends it

HN recommends it as a short, solid walkthrough of why American trains are slow and limited, most notably because freight gets priority.

This is worth your 8 minutes of time. — HN, 2019

Business & economics (other) · Transit, cities & urban planning

Subtitles (excerpt)

Let’s face it: trains kinda suck in America. They’re slow, expensive, and just don’t exist in many parts of the country. The simple reason for this is because the US is so sparsely populated. Aside from here, here, and here, cities just aren’t close enough together to make train travel faster or cheaper than plane travel. When cities are within 200-300 miles of each other, it’s often faster to take a train from downtown to downtown rather than driving to an airport, checking in, going through security, flying, then driving downtown. However, as I mentioned, there definitely are regions in the US with cities this distance away from each other, so why do trains still suck? The United States has the geography to support trains in certain areas and yet a train from DC to New York costs at least $49 dollars and takes 3 hours and 29 minutes, only 30 minutes less than driving. A train from Rennes to Paris, France, a very similar distance, costs 27 euros, the equivalent of 30 dollars, and takes only 2 hours and 4 minutes. The US does have one high speed train, the Acela express, but it costs at least $120 dollars for a ride from DC to New York and still takes 2 hours and 50 minutes. Turkey, Poland, and Uzbekistan all have trains

On Hacker News

Trains in the US are widely prevalent! It's just that they're used for freight rather than passenger travel. The main driver behind this is the population density of the USA, cities are spaced too far apart to make passenger travel by train viable. Not coincidentally, the only area that does have significant passenger rail networks, the DC - Boston corridor, has population density similar to West… — Manuel_D, 2022-07
I might be wrong but this seems like a very US-centric idea. For most of the developed world trains fill this need very well, while the US has had problems with their rail network for reasons partially based on geography, partially based on population density, and partially based on their own fault. I think this explains it pretty well: [VIDEO] The solution is not aircraft, the solution is more a… — SahAssar, 2020-08
This is worth your 8 minutes of time. [VIDEO] I love trains, but the economics of rail travel in the USA can't be overcome. Until robot trains. — NoNameHaveI, 2019-03
Wendover Productions has a good video that explains this and many other reasons why trains suck in the US [VIDEO] Spoiler: freight companies own most of the track — trimbo, 2018-04
They have trains but all track is owned by freight train providers. Here's a good overview why. [VIDEO] — sunir, 2017-07

Related videos