Bertrand's Paradox (with 3blue1brown) - Numberphile

Channel:Numberphile · Length:10:43 · Published:2021-12-20 · Views:1432187

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Numberphile interviews Grant Sanderson of 3blue1brown about Bertrand's paradox, where different reasonable ways of picking a random chord of a circle give different probabilities.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in threads on random sampling as a clear illustration of how reasonable-sounding random choices can give biased results.

there's a Numberphile / 3B1B video about the pitfalls of plotting randomness in a circle — HN, 2023

Probability & game theory · Recreational & visual math

Subtitles (excerpt)

So I want to tell you about a classic paradox in probability that is sort of a cautionary tale for students when they're about to hear a puzzle or they're setting up some kind of problem; Bertrand's paradox. There was a person who wrote this probability textbook, last name Bertrand. He mentioned in there why you have to be very careful with probabilities when infinity is involved. So what I'm going to do is have a circle and I'm going to draw a random chord somewhere in that circle. So a chord is something that just connects two different points on that circle right? What I want to ask is a certain question about the distribution of the length of this chord. You know, there's some kinds where if it just glances through the circle that length will be very short, if it went through the diameter that length would be very long. One of the most natural questions you might ask is something about the mean of that length; but that turns out to be a little on the messier side for the cleanliness of what Bertrand wanted to do. So instead he says, compare that length to the length of the sides of an equilateral triangle that's inscribed in that circle, which might seem kind of weird, like why are we talking about triangles? But it turns out

On Hacker News

So points in a circle is pretty basic, but it does remind me of a nice 3Blue1Brown video ( [VIDEO] ) about random chords of a circle. Some of these 'generate a random sample' situations can be quite non-obvious. edit: The video is about 'Bertrand's Paradox' that another post references. — Dave_Rosenthal, 2022-05
I was always surprised at how easily you get biased sampling when generating random points despite all input - something I often saw students do was essentially normalize({2 rand() - 1, 2 rand() - 1, 2 rand() - 1}) or variations of that (where rand() is "good" not the literal rand(3)), and there are numerous other ways that are more subtly wrong. IIRC the nominally correct way for a sphere specif… — olliej, 2024-03
In a related vein, there's a Numberphile / 3B1B video about the pitfalls of plotting randomness in a circle: [VIDEO] — zootboy, 2023-05

Related videos