Mach-E Thermal System Part 2: A Detailed Comparison to the Model Y

Channel:Munro Live · Length:12:27 · Published:2021-07-16 · Views:225119

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Munro Live's team breaks down the thermal management system of the Ford Mustang Mach-E and compares it with the Tesla Model Y. They look at parts count, coolant loops and heating approaches.

Why HN recommends it

Cited as engineering evidence that Tesla's integrated thermal design is far simpler than Ford's, in EV and quality debates.

Another fun one is Munro's comparison of the thermal management systems for a Model Y and Ford Mach-E — HN, 2023

Repair, teardowns & right to repair · Cars, EVs & motorcycles

Subtitles (excerpt)

Hey. Hi, boys and girls. Uh, today we're going to do a little bit of a comparison. Uh, you've already heard us talk a little bit about uh the heating and cooling system that we've got here on the Tesla Model Y. Today, what we're going to do is we're going to compare this we're going to compare the the Model Y heating and cooling system to what we found on the Mache. And I think you're going to be surprised by the differences that we've found today as well. We're going to have uh Corey Stuben, our president, and Ben Lindamood, who's uh in charge of the uh the tear down here on the on the Maky. They're going to be doing most of the talking because quite frankly, um this is a really complicated system and I don't want to bugger it up. So, I'm going to start off with Corey and he's going to start talking a little bit about what we found here uh on the Tesla and then as he's talking, Ben is going to be showing you the corresponding componentry and whatnot that's associated with uh with the Mache. So, with that, Corey, it's all yours. I'm going to get out of the way. Now, the first thing I want people to notice here is location, location, location. Many of the components for the Tesla Model Y are very close together.

On Hacker News

Tesla's manufacturing has come a long way in the past few years. In 2018, Sandy Munro famously tore down the new Model 3 with a lot of criticism for things like their excess of parts, fasteners, and welds. They made a lot of changes, including some he suggested, and now Munro tends to rave about how well they're engineered for ease of manufacture. This is a guy who gets paid by Big 3 auto compani… — DennisP, 2023-12
> The problem is that driving EVs in the cold costs a lot more energy. I've got a Ford Mustang Mach E Nowadays this problem isn't "EVs," it's mostly just the Mach E. The Mach E delivers heat in the most inefficient way possible: resistive heat[0]. Modern EVs from other manufacturers use heat pumps, which are much more efficient. There's still some drop in winter range (like gas cars), but it's no… — schiffern, 2023-11
Clearly you are not going to be convinced because you came into this conversation with a conclusion and backtracked from that just like the other poster. That is a common problem when discussing both Tesla and Apple. Both companies evoke a lot of emotion and "foaming at the mouth" type responses. Both companies have continued track records of producing stellar engineering. But for anyone else rea… — nebula8804, 2023-02
Active battery management is common to all EVs now - only the first gen Leaf and other weird niche vehicles like that don't have it. What Tesla does is an incredibly refined, efficient and integrated hardware coupled with great software. If you watch Munro's teardown of the new Model S, they basically state that they don't think it can really be improved. It's basically head and shoulders above t… — martythemaniak, 2022-03
From what I've seen from cars being put apparat by Sandy Munro company the complexity of EV cooling system maps roughly 1 to 1 with ICE. Both need cooling loops basically. There is however a staggering difference between companies. Compare cooling in Ford Mustang Mach-E and Tesla Model Y. Tesla just brutally crashes Ford in how much they are able to reduce number of parts, especially hoses and ho… — Isinlor, 2021-08

Related videos