Using ground relays with Starlink

Channel:Mark Handley · Length:10:15 · Published:2019-12-21 · Views:506104

Watch on YouTube

Summary

Mark Handley of UCL explains, with simulation visualizations, how early Starlink satellites without inter-satellite links could still give low-latency wide-area communication by hopping via ground relays. He shows it can beat fibre on many long paths.

Why HN recommends it

Cited in Starlink latency debates as a clear visual analysis showing sub-100ms latency is plausible even without inter-satellite links.

as Mark Handley has elegantly pointed out in his incredible video — HN, 2020

Networking & internet infrastructure · Space exploration & spaceflight

Subtitles (excerpt)

in May 20 19 SpaceX launched the first 60 satellites that they hugely ambitious styling low Earth orbit constellation Itza followed in November by another 60 satellites and they plan to launch another 60 around the end of the year well exactly how a SpaceX plans to operate this constellation we gather quite a bit of information from their FCC filings and from public comments by Elon Musk and Gwynne Shotwell in this video I'm gonna look at how such a constellation might work given what we know at the moment very might I don't have any inside information so this is what they could do if they wanted to but probably isn't what they'll actually do this is the underside of one of the first styling satellites those gray panels are phased array antennas and they allow the satellite to steer very narrow radio beams so you can communicate with many ground stations at the same time without needing to move a dish around as it passes by it 27,000 kilometers per hour same principles used by modern Wi-Fi base stations but while they use just a few antennas to focus power in the general direction of your phone each of those gray panels consists of 100 or more small antennas they can focus a radio beam only a couple of degrees wide they

On Hacker News

I would highly recommend the video linked from this article: [VIDEO] It's a simulation of the various ways in which the Starlink network could be arranged to route between satellites and ground stations; very detailed and super interesting. — thamer, 2020-10
You don't need inter-satellite links for low latency, as Mark Handley has elegantly pointed out in his incredible video. I don't think internet access will amount to even 50% of the revenue of Starlink. [VIDEO] — sneak, 2020-06
This [1] is a good youtube explanation of how a hybrid between Starlink and ground stations could still improve connectivity: [1] [VIDEO] — gadders, 2020-06
If you want a really great visualization and latency estimates for starlink check out the models and videos this guy came up with: [LINK] [VIDEO] The comment from the FCC about it not accounting for "processing [&] routing" is kindof nonsense on its face, those are not novel problems they're already done by ever other router and switch, including several other satellite networks. — cagenut, 2020-06
The orbital planes top parts are all up there at high latitudes. The circle you are seeing is actually made up of several different orbital planes that swoop down toward/past the equator and then up/down to 60 degrees N/S. Seeing them move will make it clearer. Here’s an awesome visual explanation with a ton of other cool info: [VIDEO] — sneak, 2020-06

Related videos