EEVblog 1637: Solar Freakin' Space Mirrors! - Reflect Orbital DEBUNKED
Channel:EEVblog · Length:22:48 · Published:2024-09-02 · Views:113494
Summary
EEVblog's Dave Jones critiques Reflect Orbital's plan to sell sunlight to solar farms after dark using orbital mirrors. He walks through the numbers to show the idea does not work out.
Why HN recommends it
HN cites it as a debunking whenever the space mirror startup comes up, as a TL;DW that the design is impractical.
Space exploration & spaceflight · Renewables, batteries & storage
Subtitles (excerpt)
We are putting reflector satellites in space to shine sunlight onto solar farms after dark. We really are prototyping a new form of energy here. Like it's like building a new nuclear reactor or something like that. We're here because for some reason people just accept that the sun goes down at night. And there's billions of dollars of solar farms around the world that get absolutely no sunlight after the sun goes down. He text me one day being like I think we can put these mirrors in space and sell the sunlight to solar farms, at which point I was in. I couldn't stop really imagining what it would be like to stand in a sunlight spot that we generated ourselves. See the beam. Oh my god. Oh, we got a flash. We got it. Hell yeah. Let there be light. Hang on. What's that you can smell? Yeah, impractical Hi. Thanks to everyone who sent me this in. It's making the news. It's been around for a couple of years actually. Yeah, there's a company called Reflectorble. Yes, they want to put satellites in space. Yes, they're deadly serious. Yes, they have funding. And they want to reflect sunlight at night or at dawn and dusk actually onto solar farms. So can this work? Yeah, it can. Is it practical? Hell no.
On Hacker News
First, they don't exist and 10k of them will never exist. Second, nothing would happen, the power will be minuscule and last for a very short time focused on such a small patch. see: [VIDEO] — reader9274, 2026-07
YT video going into the math and physics involved: [VIDEO] TL;DW: not practical in it's current design. — sxp, 2025-02
This has long been debunked e.g. by Thunderf00t ( [LINK] ) and EEVblog ( [VIDEO] ) It comes as no surprise this won't work when you imagine 1) where you have to put the mirrors: either in low orbit so as to keep light dispersion low and the apparent mirror size from the ground big—but now you have the problem that the mirrors move with high speed relative to the ground, and the time frame where y… — DemocracyFTW2, 2024-10
Found a rather... skeptical take (I'd argue it's more of a takedown)[0]. A bit crazy how far off the math is from viability, for a company that someone actually invested money in. Impressive salesmanship though. [0] [VIDEO] — kspacewalk2, 2024-10
Related videos
- Light Years Ahead | The 1969 Apollo Guidance Computer · TNMoC · 1:21:22
- The Solar Gravitational Lens will Map Exoplanets. Seriously. · Launch Pad Astronomy · 23:32
- Václav Smil at Driva Climate Investment Meeting 2019 · Nysnø Klimainvesteringer · 52:10
- Why Heat Pumps are Immensely Important Right Now · Technology Connections · 21:03
- 34C3 - The Ultimate Apollo Guidance Computer Talk · media.ccc.de · 1:01:41
- Falcon Heavy Test Flight · SpaceX · 34:19
- I Was SCARED To Say This To NASA... (But I said it anyway) - Smarter Every Day 293 · SmarterEveryDay · 1:05:19
- Michael Moore Presents: Planet of the Humans | A Film by Jeff Gibbs | Full Documentary · Michael Moore · 1:39:57
- Starbase Tour with Elon Musk [PART 1 // Summer 2021] · Everyday Astronaut · 53:17
- Carl Sagan - Pale Blue Dot · carlsagandotcom · 3:31
- Apollo Guidance Computer Part 1: Restoring the computer that put man on the Moon · CuriousMarc · 21:03
- Ground Source / Geothermal Heat Pumps and Other Info · Technology Connections · 28:04
- Dr. Robert Zubrin with a brilliant answer to "Why Should We Go To Mars?" · Jamin Gray · 4:26
- The REAL Possibility of Mapping Alien Planets! · PBS Space Time · 21:15
- How Much Do Rockets Pollute? Are They Bad For Our Air? · Everyday Astronaut · 55:45
- You are being misled about renewable energy technology. · Technology Connections · 1:32:00